Opinion : Let the experts make energy policy - Frontiersman

Let the experts make energy policy


Published on Saturday, July 14, 2007 9:01 PM AKDT

July 15, 2007

Spectrum: By Penny Nixon

This is for the Mat-Su Borough about its power plant ordinance, which is a lie masquerading as a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.

My degree is in aeronautical engineering from the Air Force Academy, where I designed, built and operated a wind turbine. Based on my research and that of thousands of other researchers and operators (as well as the fact that the Borough has destroyed both the natural gas and timber industry in the last two years), I want a clean coal plant to provide baseload electricity within the next five years like the other 50 percent of Americans with coal power.

Additionally, I want it within a mile of my house to keep the transmission costs down. I've heated my house for 15 years with wood without electricity or running water at one point in the past, so I know exactly how much energy it takes to run a home as I've provided it with my back and arms. The argument that pollution is worse now for any type of power plant using modern technology is demonstrably false. Life expectancy today is roughly double it was when electricity was first introduced. During this time period, coal was the predominant power source for most Americans and provides roughly 50 percent of the power America uses today.

The draft ordinance and its associated IM are the most laughable, childish and incompetent documents ever produced by your administration. For starters, the documents basis in California's energy policy, with the highest cost, least efficient and least reliable system in the United States is ludicrous in the extreme. Further, the Borough demonstrates total - in fact intentional - disregard for the most basic economic principles.

The Borough has demonstrated a childish disregard for skyrocketing property taxes, regulatory appropriation of private property without compensation, the inability to keep the dump from encroaching on Matanuska Electric Association's rights of way, destruction of the oil, gas and timber industry and the attempted destruction of the aviation industry, arguably one of the largest single industries in the region. For the borough to assume the regulatory burden for the energy industry is roughly equivalent to assuming the regulatory burden for the space industry. In other words, patently absurd.

My list of objections to this deceptive ordinance is lengthy, but the top of the list is the deliberately fraudulent schedule imposed on the discussion of the most critical public infrastructure project since the building of the Trans Alaska Pipeline. The idea that the Borough would draft and pass a 72-page regulatory document designed for a Stalinist central planning committee in two weeks speaks volumes about the ineptitude and deliberate anti-Americanism of the entire Borough administration.

It is clear the Borough has no intention of considering any factual data and will railroad this travesty through by deliberately shortcutting input, both from the public at large and industry experts. I publicly predicted the planning commission would pass this unedited, and I publicly predict the assembly will pass this regulation essentially unedited on Tuesday, two weeks after it was introduced.

My objections extend through the stupefyingly idiotic requirement to consider a no-build option, the notion that a smaller radius requirement exists for an airport (which can only be approached from the runway ends at shallow angles) than a heliport (which can be approached from any angle and double the approach angles) and continues through to the moronic requirement to consider the ethnology and prehistory of a gravel pit used for 40 years.

My objections go on to the assumption that all applicants are liars and require establishing accuracy of photo simulations; that a 50 MW plant size has any bearing whatsoever other than decreasing efficiency over the required power output; and the assumption that so-called renewable sources of power are desirable, technically feasible,or efficient.

In particular, the idea of geothermal power or a dam on Lake Chakachamna seems to be free unless you consider the cost of financing, building, insuring and operating the plant or building the $50 million transmission line. The last attempt to build a large hydroelectric powerplant in Alaska ended in a morass of regulation and screeching by enviro-whackos. I've walked the flanks of Pinatubo, Vesuvius, Spur, Katmai and Mt. St. Helens where the ash is hundreds of feet deep and the pyroclastic flows melted steel and sand in their path. Anyone who builds a power plant on the side of an active volcano like Spur is not merely stupid, but insane.

Finally, and incredibly, this ordinance wouldn't apply to a nuclear power plant (arguably the most cost effective and least polluting over a 100 year span) or a wind farm (arguably the least efficient and most disruptive use of land imaginable). Even the socialist country of France realizes that nuclear plants can produce 80 percent of its required power cheaper and more independently from foreign or hostile energy sources than other methods.

In conclusion, I'm quite happy with MEA's operations and staff and the MEA board elected from the public at large. They have a long and successful record of efficient and expert operations in the energy sector. Let's let the experts produce electricity and the Borough can get back to making Central Communist Party five-year plans that turn to dust 15 minutes after the ink is dry.

If you pass this ordinance, you and the 23,500 unemployed Borough resident adults should all go home and start cutting down trees to dry out wood. You're going to need it when the power goes out. I've cut five already and fueled my generator.

Comments

12 comment(s)

    nexQuimimip wrote on Feb 14, 2009 3:07 PM:

    " In everyday, largest search techniques are faster than a Wikipedia search. no teach what, because the search mechanism's inconsistency is based on when the put was indexed, the search may not proffer newly created nursemaids. Similarly, the search motor's cornersd deviating of the era firmness not be as up-to-old-fashioned as the concatenate to Wikipedia itself. Also, when proffering Wikipedia articles in a semi-annual search, mirrors and forks of Wikipedia ment viagra online prevalently goof up higher than the positive Wikipedia articles because of search motor optimization techniques. "

    Donna wrote on Feb 6, 2009 7:14 AM:

    " I have been trying to reach LTC Carlson since I left Makiminato Okinawa in 1985.

    I would like to contact him if anyone can get him my e-mail address it would be greatly appreciated.

    Donna J. Hoover (formerly Donna J. Groleau) "

    Halcrow wrote on Nov 8, 2008 2:27 PM:

    " What a wonderful, pertinent article.

    Alas, even if it should make its way over to corporate Diebold, it'll be dismissed as the irrelevent raving of an unrecognized voter (unrecognized, courtesy of Diebold). Only in America. "

    Pantloath wrote on Jul 1, 2008 10:39 AM:

    " i'm sured that it interestingly a rifleman goes to war helpful information landlord grants rifle asset protection court It's hole rifle stock thumb interesting information desert eagle .50ae pistol helpful information custom pistol ruger interesting information 22 mag rifle look at it douglas rifle barrel interesting information air pistols gamo look at it best 9mm pistol look at it hk usp pistol "

    Nifoziyf wrote on May 1, 2008 7:36 AM:

    " We are glad to offer you legal and financial services, registration of citizenship and the passport, we are engaged registration of the international driving licence and certificates, we sell credit, debit and bank cards, details on our site http://www.kreditkareal.com
    About respect Administration of a portal "

    Hixintori wrote on Apr 15, 2008 9:04 PM:

    " Hi all!

    meridias capital
    G'night "

    Alfagreyus wrote on Apr 13, 2008 10:43 PM:

    " Hi!
    Without taking into account the issue of establishing a stone by God, which he won't be able to pick up, how do you think, may be something in this world, what can God never see? "

    Jourgenz wrote on Apr 2, 2008 1:24 AM:

    " It's test.
    I could't post a message... "

    chris wrote on Mar 19, 2008 7:56 AM:

    " you are dumb the sled dogs are bred for these conditions and have been used to pull sleds for longer than recorded history and have no problem doing so and about the deaths more dogs die laying at home,at least these dogs are doing what makes them happy. "

    Goomy wrote on Jan 19, 2008 2:26 PM:

    " hmmmm...very interesting!
    Thanks google "

    Tedeldemijamb wrote on Jan 15, 2008 1:51 AM:

    " The site’s very professional! Keep up the good work!
    Best jewelry links! "

    Nancy France wrote on Dec 14, 2007 11:39 AM:

    " I recieved a wonderful e-mail showing a great spirit of the Christmas season and I was touched. The Wuitschick Family are gathering up gifts and food for the Hale family for thier first Christmas (dad papa pilgrim in jail never allowed Christmas). The Hale's are living with a family of 10 more childeren in a log house on Lazy Mt. The gifts are being collected and will be presented to the family on Monday Night. If you are interested in a folow up, you can contact Mrs. Robbi Wuitschick at 745-8944. Can you imagine 25 children in one house! "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage