$200,000 a sound investment to save state’s dairy industry


Published on Thursday, December 20, 2007 11:29 PM AKST

Critics continue to lament last Friday’s unanimous decision by the state Creamery Board to request $200,000 from the state. The money would help bridge an expected three-month gap for local dairy farmers between the closure of state-owned Matanuska Maid Dairy and the opening of the new Southcentral Dairy Venture.

There are those who say local dairy farmers have had six months to prepare for a financial future without Mat Maid.

While this is partially true, it’s important to remember the board was replaced with new members charged with trying to find a way to save the dairy processing facility from closure. Early in the process, the outlook was promising as the new board uncovered inefficiencies and extravagant expenditures. It was several months before the board exposed the full extent of the dairy’s financial woes. The state won’t continue to run the dairy at a financial loss and an effort to sell the venture was also unsuccessful.

Local dairy farmers did respond to the news, working quickly to form the new Southcentral Dairy Venture and starting negotiations with the state to purchase equipment and lease the Mat Maid logo.

There are those who say $200,000 is too much to give to just a few farmers. We think $200,000 is a wise investment in our local economy and a small price to pay to save a vital Alaska industry. The loss of these dairy farmers would have a far-reaching financial impact on our economy and other agriculture efforts. Hay farmers would lose a large portion of their customer base, as would feed and seed businesses. Because culled dairy cows represent a large portion of the animals processed at Mt. McKinley Meats, the demise of the dairy industry could be the death knell for the struggling slaughterhouse as well. Even area children who participate in 4-H could suffer from the ripple effects caused by the loss of our local dairy industry.

The loss of jobs from businesses directly and indirectly related to agriculture also impacts local retailers as there is less money to spend, forcing retailers to cut costs and jobs — and so goes the economic circle.

We realize the Legislature is not in session, but that doesn’t prevent our local representatives from taking action on this issue. We urge them and Governor Palin to find the money the State Creamery Board has requested. We appreciate Rep. Mark Neuman calling us to pledge his support and commitment to help find the needed money. We hope the others will do the same.

The state routinely invests in economic development through financial incentives and other means, and $200,000 is a drop in the bucket compared to some. This isn’t a Mat Maid issue; it’s about the future of Alaska agriculture. As the state continues to work toward a goal of self-sustainability, where Alaska could support itself in case it is cut off from the Lower 48 or Canada for any length of time, the ability to produce our own dairy products is vital to this goal.

If the effort to save Mat Maid Dairy was worth $600,000, surely saving the state’s dairy industry is worth a third that investment.

The $600,000 the Legislature appropriated to help Mat Maid survive can’t be used for another purpose, like tiding dairy farmers over, and is expected to be used to help offset costs associated with shutting Mat Maid down.

Can the governor come up with $200,000 from her discretionary spending fund? Can the commissioner reallocate funds from the budget? In this day of record-high oil prices and the state finding itself in the enviable position of having a budget surplus, we are confident the money can be found if the governor and our representatives work together to look for it.

Comments

11 comment(s)

    C.W. wrote on Dec 23, 2007 11:18 PM:

    " How can you state "The money (another $200,000) would bridge an expected three month gap."? In your very own paper on Nov. 8 Beus states they could begin by Dec 14-15. In your Dec. 1 paper Beus says "The race is on to have the SouthCentral Dairy set up enough to accept milk without a lag." The board and the governor had been told they would be ready. State is not responsible for this fiasco. They already got $650,000 Federal money, Stop throwing money away on this ongoing problem. "

    milkmancometh wrote on Dec 23, 2007 5:07 PM:

    " Andrew Halcro has posted a response to this editorial on his website. www.andrewhalcro.com I do find it odd that nobody has had the guts to admit the previous Ag board which included Valley neighbors, were right on target about this being a losing mission. "

    Oldtimer wrote on Dec 23, 2007 2:31 PM:

    " Many of you may not remember the early days here in the state when it was powdered or evaporated milk. Fresh milk was expensive and with the loss of the Maid, it's gonna get that way again. Then instead of some of you complaining about the state or the governor, you'll be crying about the price of milk. Then the only ones who will be able to afford fresh milk will be the very rich and the WIK mothers. "

    RED wrote on Dec 22, 2007 3:25 PM:

    " What about all of the other Dairymen in the last 20 years that went out of production? Save this article you can use it in 2009. "

    Palinania wrote on Dec 22, 2007 1:36 PM:

    " While the state shouldn't be in the milk processing business, just wait until you see the price of milk and milk products when/if we no longer have a local source. Outside companies have long tried to remove that competition for the very rea$son of having a captive market$$. Now, let us watch the price of a gallon of milk$$. "

    Palin fan wrote on Dec 22, 2007 1:26 PM:

    " This needs help now -- but just until the other options are available for the milk. Legislators aren't able to do anything until January 2008. So for now, it truly is in the hands of our wonderful governor. She will provide: Palin vows to rescue dairy Saturday, June 16th, 2007 ‘Things are kind of a mess … we’re going to clean it up,’ she pledges By ANDREW WELLNER awellner@adn.com Published: June 16, 2007 Last Modified: June 16, 2007 at 02:14 AM WASILLA — A shiny silver Matanuska Maid milk tanker .... "

    jess wrote on Dec 22, 2007 8:22 AM:

    " thanks Rep. Neuman for trying to help the dairy farmers. I hope that someday the schools and parents will teach the child that milk does not just come from super markets. "

    Jillian wrote on Dec 22, 2007 12:56 AM:

    " STOP THE BLEEDING! Palin is a disaster. Don't blame me, I didn't vote for her. "

    Faganite "thinking" wrote on Dec 21, 2007 10:31 PM:

    " Thanks, Becky, for parroting the tired talking points of Dan Fagan and Andrew Halcro. The real truth, from a strict business sense, is that the state should have gotten out of the dairy business decades ago. Then REAL money could have been saved. What has been spent in the last few months was a drop in the bucket, but it did give some hard-working Alaskans a shot at a soft landing, instead of leaving them high and dry. Nothing wrong with that. "

    becky wrote on Dec 21, 2007 12:02 PM:

    " Another example of why government should not be in business. Mat Maid should have been closed months ago and saved all of us millions. Keeping it open was a poor, poor decision. "

    Neumania wrote on Dec 21, 2007 12:17 AM:

    " What a posturing good-for-nothing Neuman is. Apparently by pledging "his support and commitment to help find the needed money," he means "pass the buck to the governor." What a sorry excuse for a leader. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage