Palin gets passing grade from political science profs

By Sarah Anne Carter
For the Frontiersman
Published on Thursday, September 4, 2008 9:13 PM AKDT

Good. Effective. Energetic. Spunky.

Those are the words used by some political science professors to describe Gov. Sarah Palin’s speech Wednesday night at the Republican National Convention in Minnesota.

“It can’t be an easy thing to do,” said Don Crowley, University of Idaho professor and chair of the school’s Political Science Department. “She comes across as very energetic and feisty. It seems she intends to play the role vice presidential candidates often assume — an attack dog against the other party … and she seems capable of playing it.”

Another political science professor, Henry Brady of the University of California Berkeley, described Palin as “spunky” and referred to the “Mary Tyler Moore” television show when her editor tells her she has spunk.

“I think for the first time in the convention, the Republicans didn’t feel stodgy and desperate,” he said. “It hit a note that was important for the Republican Party.”

Alaskans, though, may not have been as surprised as others with how well she did.

“I think she laid to rest any doubts friendly people had about whether she was capable or competent,” said James Muller, University of Alaska Anchorage professor of political science. “With the experience Alaskans have with her, we’re probably less surprised that she did so well.”

Gerald McBeath, University of Alaska Fairbanks professor and chair of the Political Science Department, said he thought it was an impressive speech and noticed that Palin didn’t dress in her usual bright colors, probably wanting to keep the focus on her words.

“She also didn’t tell her story completely,” McBeath said. “My guess is that she did not want to steal any thunder from (Sen. John) McCain.”

He also noted that McCain joining Palin on stage at the end of her speech shows a strong gesture of support.

While she emphasized her conservative credentials, she didn’t focus on a lot of specific issues.

“She’s a good and engaging speaker and she shored up her conservative credentials,” said Matt Barreto, University of Washington assistant professor of political science. She’s popular with conservative Christians, which is an important base for McCain to reach, he said.

However, another professor was looking for her to talk about the issues.

“It was free of any policy content, but a lot of one-liners directed at Obama and the Democrats,” Crowley noted. “She supports energy development, but beyond that it was hard to find a lot of content.”

Comments

5 comment(s)

    LARRY OINAS wrote on Sep 6, 2008 5:34 PM:

    " ALASKANS YOU ARE FORTUNATE TO HAVE SARAH.WE NEED TO BORROW HER FOR A WHILE TO FINISH OFF THE DEMS. "

    steve in Indiana wrote on Sep 6, 2008 1:19 PM:

    " Facinating to watch a Governor get hit immediately as "too inexperienced" and "smug" for challenging Obama's community organizer work as not being as not being equal to a mayor who must hire, fire, make budgets, fix potholes, keep garbage collection and snow removal working, etc. Please list what Obama did as community org. Oops - media hasn't really covered that have they. By the way, our forefathers wrote the qualifications for President in the Constitution. You must be 36 and born here. She is QUALIFIED!!! "

    Mark wrote on Sep 5, 2008 6:14 PM:

    " We love her in Michigan and am so glad she's in the race. I'll be praying every day that she hangs tough against the left-wing media. Go girl!

    PS. Visited Alaska on vacation this summer and it was great! "

    Dennis Nelson wrote on Sep 5, 2008 5:14 PM:

    " Gov. Palin denies global warning as scientific fact, at odds with John McCain. She advocates the teaching of "intelligent design" in schools. We don't yet know her position on other scientific issues. She is also against sex education for teenagers although teen pregnancies are on the rise in every state, including Alaska,for the first time in fourteen years. Alaska also has the highest per-capita incidence of chlamydia in the country. Palin is also embroiled in a full-scale investigation by the state legislature into the alleged wrongful dismissal of the public safety commissioner. "

    Michael wrote on Sep 5, 2008 1:58 PM:

    " (from Pennsylvania)

    Thank you for letting us borrow her Alaska. I know some wanted her to speak on policy but I think she was perfect. She came out and showed the elitists that they will have to talk issues because she is going to stand her ground.

    I think you should be proud of her. I am grateful to see her as a positive female role model for my daughter and she surely helps secure my vote this year. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage