Fallout unclear for Palin

By Michael Rovito
Frontiersman
Published on Tuesday, October 14, 2008 6:40 AM AKDT

ALASKA — Now that the long-anticipated Troopergate report has concluded Gov. Sarah Palin abused the governor’s office while trying to get her former brother-in-law fired from the Alaska State Troopers, the question is what the report will do to her politically.

Since the report was made public Friday, stories in major newspapers across the world detail a family feud that spilled into Alaska’s highest office.

The conclusion Palin, the Republican vice presidential candidate, used her position for personal purposes also comes at a time when Republican presidential candidate John McCain is falling even further behind Democrat Barack Obama in national polls.

A spokesman for the Obama campaign said officials there are letting voters decide if the Troopergate report will affect Palin’s vice presidential aspirations. Nathan Osburn, the Obama spokesman, said the abuse of power violation determined in the Troopergate report is reminiscent of the country’s current administration.

“We’ve seen repeated abuses of power from the Bush administration,” Osburn said. “And that’s one of the reasons Americans are cynical of politics.”

A call to the McCain-Palin campaign seeking comment was not returned by press time.

On Saturday, however, in a conference call with Alaska reporters, Palin said the report cleared her of any unethical activity.

According to a transcript of the call, Palin was reminded the No. 1 finding of the report states she abused her power and violated state law.

In response, Palin said she thinks “you’re always going to ruffle feathers as you do what you believe is in the best interest of the people whom you are serving.”

The original intent of the Troopergate investigation was to find out if Palin abused her power by trying to get her former brother-in-law fired.

The report that came out Friday did two things: it reaffirmed Palin’s right to fire former Public Safety Commissioner Walt Monegan and it said she did abuse her power.

Still, Nov. 4 is three weeks away, and anything can happen in that time. But just how much impact the Troopergate report will have on the McCain-Palin ticket depends on who you ask.

“I think given where the McCain-Palin ticket stands today, it’s a marginal factor,” said University of Alaska Fairbanks political science professor Gerald McBeath.

McBeath said voters tend to treat controversies like Troopergate differently because it involves a family dispute as opposed to rewarding cronyism.

Voters are more likely to dismiss something like Troopergate than a situation where a governor gives unethical rewards to a subordinate, McBeath said. That’s on the national scale; in Alaska, it could be a different story. Since Palin joined the national ticket her approval rating in the state has steadily declined.

Pollster Ivan Moore said Monday the latest poll shows Palin with a 60 percent approval rating and 30 percent negative in Alaska.

Those numbers may please most governors of other states. But in Palin’s case, her 60 percent approval rating is down from a high of nearly 85 percent before she was tapped for the Republican ticket.

Factors often noted as contributing to Palin’s rating decline are her role as attacker for McCain and some claims and assertions the ticket has made on the campaign trail that were disproved soon after, Moore said.

Moore said he expects Palin’s approval ratings to drop even further in Alaska now that it’s been determined she abused her office.

“I suspect it’s going to hurt her,” Moore said, adding a new poll gauging Alaskans’ approval of Palin will come out next Monday.

Since Palin’s ascension to the national stage Aug. 29, the media has been fascinated with the little-known governor from an often misunderstood state. The fascination appears to have brought to the surface more negative press than Palin has ever received before during her political career in Alaska.

The Troopergate controversy, which began as an issue rarely talked about outside Alaska, became a story in the Lower 48 when McCain picked Palin.

Following Friday’s release of the report, Rep. Bill Stoltze, R-Chugiak, said the media will have a role in shaping voters’ perception of the Troopergate controversy depending on how they report it.

McBeath said if McCain doesn’t win the presidency it’s important to remember Palin will come back to Alaska as the governor.

What will happen then is unclear. McBeath said it’s safe to say Palin’s previously sterling relationship with many House and Senate Democrats is tarnished, and the full Legislature could vote to censure her.

There hasn’t been talk of that yet, but many progressive bloggers are starting concerted efforts to circulate recall petitions among Alaskans.

“The honeymoon is over,” McBeath said.

The state’s Personnel Board is also investigating the Troopergate scandal, and Palin has said the board is the correct body to run such an investigation.

The board has hired Anchorage trial attorney Timothy Petumenos, a Democrat who contributed to Palin’s opponent, Tony Knowles, during the 2006 gubernatorial election, to run the investigation.

It’s unclear when the Personnel Board’s report will be complete.

Contact Michael Rovito at michael.rovito@frontiersman.com or 352-2252.

Comments

40 comment(s)

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Oct 28, 2008 5:47 AM:

    " RE: valleymom's commet that "Only the ignorant outsiders and democrats have negative views"... Here's what McCAIN AIDs are now saying: ""She is a diva. She takes no advice from anyone. She does not have any relationships of trust with any of us, her family or anyone else. She is playing for her own future and sees herself as the next leader of the party. Remember: Divas trust only unto themselves, as they see themselves as the beginning and end of all wisdom." "

    Exactly wrote on Oct 26, 2008 5:26 PM:

    " I think he/they were just trying to use their new found power to settle a score. "

    Which speaks to the small minded "Jerry Springer" type of mentality that Governs your state!.

    She too ignnorant to know just how ignorant she is! "

    valleymom wrote on Oct 25, 2008 6:51 PM:

    " If you doan't want Sarah as VP we will take her back with open arms. You Alaskans who slam her but enjoy the money she gave to the people are nothing but fakes. And those outsiders that slam her are complete idiots. Yes, we'll take her back and keep the oil for our state to use. Some of you viewers need to go back to school. If you want to slam someone, at least learn how to spell. Maybe we should't allow outsiders to work in our state and take the money out. Protect Alaska from these idiots. "

    valleymom wrote on Oct 25, 2008 6:37 PM:

    " My family & I are Proud of Gov Palin and her family. Only the ignorant outsiders and democrats have negative views of Gov Palin. Being a Valley resident for almost 20 years, we have seen what Sarah can do and has done for the Valley and the state. PEOPLE WAKE UP! If the democrats take over we could lose our PFD, gun rights, lose jobs associated with our resources. I refuse to lose 1/2 of my income so they can give my hard earned money to support the welfare system. Go Sarah! VALLEY GIRLS KICK BUTT!!! "

    anotherREALAmerican wrote on Oct 22, 2008 5:50 AM:

    " Looks like Palin will be sent home after this election. Good for America, bad for Alaska. I hope you guys are ready to enjoy your corrupt, silly Governor again. "

    AnnieOkie wrote on Oct 19, 2008 6:17 AM:

    " Proud AlaskanAmerican????

    Curious to know....who is this MESSIAH you speak of? Surely, your not trying to belittle, trash who ever you think this MESSIAH is...EH? I believe you need to look up the meaning of the word
    HYPROCRITE ! "

    AnnieOkie wrote on Oct 19, 2008 6:01 AM:

    " Proud AlaskanAmerican????
    If I interpreted your post correctly, you are saying, there is no way you would help out your fellow Americans who has fallen on hard times...CORRECT?There are so many people, through no fault of their own, who need a helping hand. Do you think by giving a little extra out of your paycheck is going to put you in the poor house..take food out of your mouth? I suggest you go to New Orleans, Galveston TX, or lets say..walk the streets of the cities where some of our homeless vets live..
    ProudAlaskanAmerican..change your moniker..it doesnt fit you ! "

    Proud AlaskanAmerican wrote on Oct 18, 2008 10:13 PM:

    " Good for you Valley Girl! These other people who have nothing else to do but belittle, trash, says they are the "Messiahs" groupies. Real Alaskans no the truth, wait till they have to support the unemployed, homeless, and welfare people with they're income not their families, they will cry all the way home as the little piggy said. "

    Valley Girl wrote on Oct 18, 2008 10:17 AM:

    " Yup, the SAME people writing more crap!!! Any story about the Palins... in the comments.. the same people!!!
    Spreading the HATE!!! LET THOSE WHO HAVE NOT SINNED CAST THE FIRST STONE!!
    GOD BLESS AMERICA,ALASKA, AND THE PALIN FAMILY! "

    pleasetakeherback wrote on Oct 17, 2008 12:00 PM:

    " Many I speak to here in the lower 48 wish you would just her back up to Alaska and keep her there. You poor people! If Mccain gets elected, we are one melanoma away from her being VP. How scary is that? She's anti-black, anti-gay, anti-choice,a hate monger,and her husband won't survive in DC. I'm not looking forward to paying for her commute to AK. I'm all for breaking the glass ceiling but not at the expense of my children and my integrity. She's a piece of work. "

    Mare wrote on Oct 17, 2008 11:25 AM:

    " I think Alaska is a beautiful state and would do better without the likes of the Palins. Abuse of power is not to be taken lightly. It all sounds so familiar the way Bush/Cheney, etal dragged the constution through the mud. We don't need the likes of her/him in any public office. Separation of church and state is a must. I feel that the Palins owe Mr. Monegan AND Trooper Wooten a BIG. apology. "

    Karin Byars wrote on Oct 17, 2008 10:34 AM:

    " JP-
    You need to get out of the woods! It is no longer cool to be racist or Republican, or negative about everything or uneducated or a recluse or a secessionist.

    Real Americans look forward, they see the positive side of things, they work together to make good things happen. They educate their children they protect each other and they cherish the natural beauty around them. Looking through crosshairs gives you tunnel vision. McCain has about as much life left in him as that old truck of yours.

    Get real, see the light! "

    AnnieOkie wrote on Oct 17, 2008 7:22 AM:

    " Even though Sarah Palin has the title Governor...its really Todd Palin calling the shots.Sarah is just his hand puppet. Todd knew he could not run for Governor because of his ties with the AIP.We have all seen by Sarah's words and actions..she is not to bright. Seeing that Todd has lost control of his hand puppet , we are now getting a birds eye view..of the true Sarah Palin..Hateful..Mean..Nasty..Dishonest..Uneducated...etc...etc ! IMO "

    Ed from Tucson wrote on Oct 16, 2008 8:33 PM:

    " Shameful, she abuses power, gets caught, has a bi-partisan committee ask for investigation, changes her mind from co-operation to non co-operation, suggests the investigation is partisan politics, and finally after report is issued states she was proven innocent of all charges including unethical abuse of power.

    You betcha, she is an arrogant piece of dog dirt who should punished with time behind bars after her impeachment. Anyone who disagrees should return to school to re learn word meanings. "

    Lisa Ca wrote on Oct 16, 2008 5:54 PM:

    " This is one dumb Woman...She is very very cruel...How can she incite people to yell kill Obama....Obama, has a wife
    and two beautiful children...Also there is a lot of Crazy people out there and she is one of them...And that idiot JP
    that says he is a raciest shame on you ..You better stay where your at because, you wouldn't get away with that in our town... Impeach Palin and her my Dog Spot husband that is always right behide her... "

    alaska74 wrote on Oct 16, 2008 4:23 PM:

    " Gov. Palin had no business bringing her personal life or her husband into state business. Not only is what she did appalling, but her statement after found guilty of abusing her power that she was glad she was vindicated shows that she either didn't understand what she read, or chose to ignore reality. Both options are inexcusable for a governmental leader. One leads by example, not words. It is so disheartening to see her continually try and bully her way through things. It's simply wrong. "

    laura wrote on Oct 15, 2008 11:14 PM:

    " Impeach Palin. An aweful woman to represent us Alaskans. "

    morgan wrote on Oct 15, 2008 9:41 PM:

    " and then she got elected and then she did something everyone liked and then those who wanted to throw her out with the bath water were all the sudden the "one" that voted for her and then. I think it funny that so many are so short sighted! "

    Jack wrote on Oct 15, 2008 8:51 PM:

    " Another head slapper from the student who must've been absent from third grade. Seems that Sarah thinks that New Hampshire is part of the great NorthWEST. This is what happens when you demand that geography books be banned from the library:)
    It is absolutely incredible to me, and now the rest of America, how someone this stupid rose to any level in government. Is this the best Alaska has to offer? Is there anyone out there who can still say with a straight face that you are proud of this woman? "

    jp wrote on Oct 15, 2008 8:06 PM:

    " heck yes, i'm racist, and so are every one of you too! but that's not why i'm not voting for the Obamanator.
    i think that most of you are voting for him for racial reasons (to prove that you are not a racist).
    the fact still remains, he has no leadership abilities, sure he can talk a mean game, but does he have the cajones to carry through with anything, or is he just a used car salesman?
    the truth is: we are voting for the lesser of two evils yet again! "

    Debbie -Ft MyersFl. wrote on Oct 15, 2008 1:11 PM:

    " I feel sorry for the people of Alaska. You get Sarah back!!! I hope you don't vote for her again. She sure fooled you. She is a very power hungry person and as we know will do and say anything to get that power. Please don't let her because as we know she will abuse it!!! "

    used to live wasilla wrote on Oct 15, 2008 12:40 PM:

    " Wow: Sure never heard of anyone from Wasilla that is a that was so stupid,until now. she has insult to Alaska. I feel sorry for all Alaskan. She makes them look like a bunch of hicks, from the bush.... "

    nursek wrote on Oct 15, 2008 11:13 AM:

    " Go to this webpage and scroll down to the letter to the editor of this newpaper from a 91 year old grandmother. I loved this letter.
    http://bangornews.com/detail/91025.html "

    Jim from Boston wrote on Oct 15, 2008 10:37 AM:

    " Her moose is cooked. He-he, I like that one.

    Gidget was in New Hampshire yesterday and said New England is pretty cool because we have moose and we fish and all that stuff.

    I still think she's kind of a dunce though. To bad about the ethics violations, her moose is cooked. "

    Janet wrote on Oct 15, 2008 10:23 AM:

    " I've watched almost all her televised speeches and she repeats the same misinformation all the time. Even when her campaign staff has been proven wrong. She just keeps on spouting the same garbage. Does she think we're that dumb out here? Would you like your VP (could be president) saying things like...darn right, you betcha...wink wink to some foreign dignitary. Not me. "

    Marie wrote on Oct 15, 2008 9:07 AM:

    " I am glad to see that not all Alaskan's are represtented by Sarah Palin. Just as McCain does not represent everyone in my state of Arizona. Everything I've been told about Alaska has been positive. That is until I met Sarah Palin. She is just so mean spirited. I'm
    sure you can't cross Sarah and get away with it. No disrespect to your state but I hope she will be home soon. Good luck and my God bless you. "

    SmellingSalt wrote on Oct 15, 2008 4:11 AM:

    " Wake up you sleepy Wasillians. Since you didn't or wouldn't put on your vetting boots- we had too. And you sweet Sarah does not pass the smell test. Now we learn that her house was built for free and by her own order no building permit required. Bailey and crew may lie for her but trades people are different, just ask Sen. Stevens. "

    Kelly wrote on Oct 14, 2008 10:38 PM:

    " IMPEACH PALIN! "

    Terri Holland wrote on Oct 14, 2008 10:36 PM:

    " It is my hope, when the election is over, and Palin returns to Alaska, that the constituency there fully investigates the actions of Sarah Palin. Her rhetoric is deceiving and her racist comments are disgusting. I feel sorry for the decent, hard working people of Alaska. Good luck to you all. "

    laura wrote on Oct 14, 2008 10:15 PM:

    " Palin is a racist liar. creating hate towards the other candidate is heartless. I am a woman from Wasilla Alaska and NEVER will I vote for Sarah Palin. She is a disgrace to the people of ALASKA. "

    Joe wrote on Oct 14, 2008 8:23 PM:

    " Wes, I did read the report and I find your assertion that she is innocent as delusional as hers. This goes far beyond
    a husband protecting his family. And we can't move on because it is not over yet, thanks to Gov. Palin filing a complaint against herself to bring this to the personnel board. A board which, by the way, has expanded their probe. Gov. Palin brought that on herself when she tried to circumvent the legislature's investigation. "

    Allie wrote on Oct 14, 2008 4:52 PM:

    " Todd was not just protecting his family, her was using the power of his spouse to settle an old family score and, it seems, to flex his power muscles. Imagine if you or I tried to pull the same nonsense in our own lives. What if the wife of a local cop decided she would use her husband's car or his badge to rattle someone she hated? Or the husband of a company-owner implied a worker would be let go if that person did not cooperate? We would be crucified. Rightfully so. "

    Jack wrote on Oct 14, 2008 4:33 PM:

    " In less than 60 days Sarah has managed: to make Alaska look like a backwater, state with her cornball vernacular and winking. This is a how a leader speaks?? Embarrassed her young pregnant daughter by dragging her and the teen father into the limelight as a "one of us." These kids need guidance and support, not a circus sideshow celebrating their foolishness as a political trophy. She very effectively, put the GOP in shambles, ruining any chances of a Mc Cain victory, made her church look like a voodoo cult and set the woman's movement back 100 years. MAVERICK!!! "

    Jack wrote on Oct 14, 2008 4:01 PM:

    " Her moose is cooked. If Sarah and Todd had just moved on with their lives ( as Wes suggests we do now) instead of going to extraordinary lengths to get Wooten fired, they wouldn't be in this mess in the first place. They brought it on themselves and any "sensationalism" by the press could have been avoided if she turned down the VP bid. Anyone with half a brain, can now clearly see, she and Todd (apparently they "govern together)even with their two brains together, were not qualified to accept the nomination. "

    Curious wrote on Oct 14, 2008 1:18 PM:

    " Innocent is just a word. Sarah's ACTIONS speak louder then any word.

    Abuse of power corrupted both the Palins.

    It was personal. No matter what authority she had, misusing it for personal gain will never equate to innocence or vindication.

    Her intensions were self serving from day one when Todd Palin spoke with Monegan. She was guilty from the get go, Monegans firing under her authority she had is secondary to her initial motives. They had a alterative motive during the initial conversation, They threw out the first pitch. Now lets playball "

    Vertigo wrote on Oct 14, 2008 12:26 PM:

    " How could anyone say she is innocent. She was found to have abused her authority and violated ethics law. How can anyone in AK feel comfortable knowing what this person would do if angered by them by anything, large or small. "

    Val wrote on Oct 14, 2008 11:01 AM:

    " I think we have enough corruption in Washington. We don't need more. If she claims to be a reformer she has a strange way of proving it. "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Oct 14, 2008 10:21 AM:

    " Wes Hamrick...you are correct, she is technically innocent and was not found to have broken a law. Let's not, however, gloss over the fact that the report commissioned by a bi-partisan vote also concluded her behavior (while technically legal) was unethical and an abuse of power. I don't believe her husband was protecting his family either. I think he/they were just trying to use their new found power to settle a score. "

    Wes Hamrick wrote on Oct 14, 2008 7:57 AM:

    " For those who READ the report, she's innocent, Sure, her husband was defending his family, I wouldn't want to try and stop any husband from doing whats right. Move on with your lives and this story. Time for the media to quit to sensationalized journalism to sell papers.... It's over "

    redcoat wrote on Oct 14, 2008 7:39 AM:

    " who does this woman think she is?

    she said the report cleared her of any unlawful or unethical wrongdoing, but it did find that she abused the powers of her office.

    palin needs to just go away!

    how anyone could vote for her as vp much less mayor of your town is unbelievable.

    even the conservative press knows that she is beyond worthless. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage