Troopergate doesn't faze Palin approval rating

By Michael Rovito
Frontiersman
Published on Thursday, October 23, 2008 8:27 PM AKDT

MAT-SU — New poll results show Gov. Sarah Palin’s popularity rating in Alaska slipping slightly, but not nearly as much as some predicted following the release of the Troopergate report.

Ivan Moore, owner of Ivan Moore Research, released new numbers Thursday showing Palin with a 64 percent positive rating and 33 percent negative rating in the state. The survey was conducted with 500 likely voters statewide and has a margin of error of plus or minus 4.4 percent. Moore said out of 500 surveys about 75 were conducted in the Mat-Su Valley.

Moore’s previous poll, taken before the Troopergate report was released, showed Palin’s rating at 64 percent positive and 30 percent negative.

“Given that the Branchflower report was made public on Oct. 10, followed by abuse of power headlines in newspapers on the 11th, it is perhaps surprising that Palin’s rating has remained quite as consistent as it has,” Moore said.

Still, yesterday’s rating is far lower than Palin’s January high of 82 percent favorable and 11 percent negative.

A spokeswoman with the McCain-Palin campaign said she had not seen the numbers yet and did not comment.

The Troopergate report found that while Palin had the right to fire former Public Safety Commissioner Walt Monegan, she abused her office by trying to get her former brother-in-law, Alaska State Trooper Michael Wooten, fired.

The state’s Legislative Council hired Stephen Branchflower as an independent investigator after a unanimous vote of eight Republicans and four Democrats to investigate Palin.

Shortly after Palin was picked as Republican presidential candidate John McCain’s running mate Aug. 29, the Troopergate probe became mired in controversy.

Palin, who initially agreed to cooperate before being named McCain’s VP pick, said the probe became too partisan and amounted to a smear campaign.

After the report went public Oct. 10, many political pundits predicted it would destroy Palin’s favorable ratings among Alaskans.

Judging by Moore’s report, those pundits were wrong.

“What this shows was that, largely, people had made up their minds” about Troopergate before the report came out, Moore said.

Moore’s report also asked three Troopergate-related questions. The answers to those questions create what appears to be a paradox.

While 53 percent of those surveyed thought pressure was placed on Monegan to fire Wooten and 48 percent said Monegan was likely fired because of Wooten, only 34 percent thought an abuse of power occurred.

The numbers show that although many Alaskans feel the Palins put pressure on the Public Safety Department to fire Wooten, most feel there was no abuse of power in the process.

“They didn’t buy the report,” Moore said of the majority of Alaskans.

That could be because of what Moore calls Palin’s dedicated base of supporters in Alaska “who support her through almost whatever happens.”

He added the so-called “Palin Truth Squad,” comprised of former Palin spokeswoman Meg Stapleton and Ed O’ Callaghan, a former U.S. prosecutor in charge of terrorism cases, could have swayed people’s thinking. The Truth Squad held almost daily press conferences to discredit the Troopergate investigation, but has since gone quiet.

To Moore, the Truth Squad wasn’t a good idea.

“They did damage control,” Moore said. “They really ticked people off.”

He added, judging by the small effect the report had on Palin’s rating, Palin likely should have cooperated because it wouldn’t have made a difference in people’s reaction to the report.

“The efforts to suppress and road-block the investigation only made them look as if they were worried as to what the findings would say,” Moore said.

The results of Moore’s survey came out less than two weeks before the presidential elections. No matter Palin’s popularity rating in the state, Alaska is expected to vote Republican Nov. 4, and the state only has three electoral votes that count toward electing a president.

Palin and her husband, Todd, are expected to give depositions in a separate Troopergate investigation run by the state’s Personnel Board Friday.

Palin filed an ethics complaint against herself with the board after she said the Legislature’s investigation had become too partisan. The Personnel Board is the proper venue to handle an investigation like Troopergate, she said.

The board hired Anchorage attorney Timothy Petumenos, a Democrat, as its independent investigator.

There has been no official word on when Petumenos will finish and release his report.

For now, at least, Palin’s popularity seems to be holding steady.

“It’s certainly good news for Sarah,” Moore said. “There had to be concern there.”

Contact Michael Rovito at michael.rovito@frontiersman.com or 352-2252.

Comments

36 comment(s)

    pop wrote on Oct 30, 2008 8:47 AM:

    " I cant belive alaska is so dumb, she wont go on any talk show to take tought questions how can anybody vote for something not knowing what they stand for what they know about world affars, she is just plain DUMB she has a lot of show but no brains, she has never been called out and forced to talk on the subjects to see how much she knows we are suckers for paying her all this money, I would like to charge the state for everthing, suckers are born evert day. "

    Valley Trash Alaskan Born wrote on Oct 29, 2008 1:03 PM:

    " Part one
    Well the Branchflower report is actually one man’s "opinion" and nothing more. His wife was Monigans secretary, and he worked with Monigan - impartial? I think not. When you work "At Will" you can be re-assigned or removed with out reason. If you are not willing to make a correction in your department that is glaringly necessary, than maybe it is time for a reassignment. I consider Wooten a huge reason. "

    Carol from Kona wrote on Oct 29, 2008 11:18 AM:

    " Greetings to all you in the upper one.
    Most of us in the offshore one are simply amazed that you would continue to support Palin and Stevens,
    As Senator Stevens said "it's an Alaskan thing". "

    steve wrote on Oct 28, 2008 3:37 PM:

    " What happened to Meg Stapelton? "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Oct 27, 2008 7:17 AM:

    " To Cheryl...why do you even post non-sense like this "Obama, Reid, Pelosi takes our rights to free speech ." You just make yourself look ignorant and make you're side look lesson appealing. Eventually you will need to move beyond this election and grow your base/support. If you carry on like a band of idiots you will have a hard time converting independents. "

    laura of Wasilla wrote on Oct 26, 2008 10:18 PM:

    " Fazes my opinion of her. The woman is out for herself. She doesnt care about Alaska or anyone else. I cant wait to see her in wasilla and let her know we all dont approve of her. White House? I think NOT "

    Oops wrote on Oct 26, 2008 8:58 PM:

    " Cheryl honey your ignorance and prejudice is showing.

    Your campaign consignment clothed governor just keeps it going and going, no wonder you're so angry. Someone give that woman a gift card to Kmart or something geez.

    You might be speechless on Nov. 4 at the UNPOPULAR rating Palin receives here in Alaska, you need to disassociate yourself from thinking you know her, she doesn't care, you're not on her agenda. "

    Doug wrote on Oct 26, 2008 4:25 AM:

    " If you want those sickened by the power hungry, off script, abuse of power, letting her husband share her power, exploit her children, lie on her taxes, racist hate filled mongering pretend christian who wants to take away women's rights to choose to be quiet, tell Sarah to step down. She's made a fool of herself, the GOP and anyone who ever said they supported her. The rest of the world wants OBAMA. And are you crazy, if you were born in the US, you're an american. Duh! "

    Kara wrote on Oct 26, 2008 4:16 AM:

    " If Sarah Palin's approval rating hasn't dropped since she exposed herself as a conceited liar who abuses her power, lies about her taxes, inflates her expenses and will stir up hatred and vile racist comments from her supportes, then the people who were polled are either living in a cave, are deaf or dare I say, a few neurons short of a synapse. The rest of the world wants Palin. Even those who appose abortion. She's a joke. I just hope that when she loses the VP, some bright person runs against her for governor "

    ed the electrician wrote on Oct 25, 2008 11:42 PM:

    " palin called the media out when she gave her coming out speech at the RNC, and she was obliged.

    if this is the GOP's hope for the future they are in deep doo-doo.

    ed the electrician "

    Cheryl wrote on Oct 25, 2008 4:49 PM:

    " Again we have the same old crap from ignorant, idiots that love to blog. Nothing positive just crap! When Obama, Reid, Pelosi takes our rights to free speech away, look at the same people crying BooHoo! Good job Obama this is what you are doing to this country, racism, bigotry and hatred. "

    akindependent wrote on Oct 25, 2008 4:19 PM:

    " Still to be investigated are conducting State business on private email accounts to keep them from public scrutiny, taxpayers paying for family travel and staying in her own home, and the story in today's LA Times about more than 100 State jobs and business loans going to her campaign donors. It's too bad we didn't learn about her lack of integrity before we elected her governor. "

    md wrote on Oct 25, 2008 2:00 PM:

    " well, Pailins approval rating in northern california is really low, I have not met one person who likes her. And, I am not an "outsider" I lived in Alaska for the past 15 years, just happen to be in CA right now.
    Palin is viewed as incompetitant here. I think she'll lose this election and will never get another chance. "

    For the People wrote on Oct 25, 2008 8:42 AM:

    " Welcome Outsiders ! Are you a racist ? We have progressed past the 1800's and the 1960's , get over it. Real America is made up of all people! This country was built by all people ! If Obama was white building a runway in Germany would you doubt that ? If he was white but born in Alaska would you doubt his birth certificate ? Give me a break ! You racist people write on blogs to release you views of hate but wont say it out loud in fear of getting beat up. "

    For Change wrote on Oct 25, 2008 8:37 AM:

    " This is for WELCOME OUTSIDERS ! At first I thought it was just Palin who was stupid in Alaska, but you have confirmed my worst nightmare, there are people like you and Palin in Alaska. I see why Todd Palin wanted to be in the Independence party. You are stupid ! Obama was born in Hawaii which is more America than Alaska, Is there a crime in having family in other countries ? Shake the ice from between your ears and stop being stupid ! I dont think everybody from Alaska is bad , but you and Palin are ! "

    Welcome Outsiders wrote on Oct 25, 2008 4:16 AM:

    " If you believe everything you read, then you would know that Barack is being accused of not even being a US citizen. You guys are worried about Palin's clothes, her makeup, her shoes, and don't even know what is going on in your own party. Have you even looked at some of the facts or accusations about him?? They are building a new runway in Kenya so Air Force One can land there. Does that not even concern you just a little?? Think about it. At least we know McCain and Palin are Americans "

    scott w wrote on Oct 25, 2008 2:49 AM:

    " No offense to Alaska, but this lady is just not qualified to be VP. I'm beginning to wonder how she got to be governor. You voted her in, you can have her back. "

    Sam wrote on Oct 24, 2008 11:35 PM:

    " Didn't the media declare Democrats the winner of the last two Presidential elections before the elections were even had?

    I could swear I seen all the media wiping the big crocodile tears from their eyes on Nov 5th.

    You people that beleive it's over because of the media need to get your heads examined. "

    Giddyup wrote on Oct 24, 2008 11:10 PM:

    " moreofsame hits the nail right on the head- what is then to prevent her from future abuse of power with regard to other troopers? Sarah is not QUEEN of Alaska and the troopers are not her subjects. Meanwhile, Todd the wannabe, plays power games in his wife's office, just to see how far he could get. It stopped being about Wooten and more about the power. Seriously, if your family felt TRULY threatened, would you play this game for two years? You would've just gone out an kicked his a**.. It was all about power. "

    Ponostutu wrote on Oct 24, 2008 7:56 PM:

    " I live in Calif, have family in both Hawaii and Alaska. What I know, is that Obama has rejected his white family for his black family. The white family paid for his education, and all the other goodies. His daughters don't even know their white greatgrandmother. I think that's a Michelle thing tho. At least when Gov Palin speaks, I feel she speaks to me, and not down to me. And I'm getting really tired of all the inuendos about Gov Palin--if she was a man, would the media be so volcanic towards him? "

    glomtt wrote on Oct 24, 2008 6:34 PM:

    " Ohio,
    Why don't you just scoop Palin up and take her with you to Ohio, where she can spew her rhetoric and vicious undocumented lies to the farm animals. America has had enough of her and McCain's divisional, un christian like, racist lies. We have also heard enough of your rhetoric also. Educate yourself. This a new day, we need people to come together not be divided. "

    Oops wrote on Oct 24, 2008 3:22 PM:

    " Who are you kidding Michael, the latest poll probably was taken outside a hockey game. Talk on the street in Palmer, she's sinking everyday. I'd give her less then 50%. Lies Baby Lies! "

    jp to more of same wrote on Oct 24, 2008 12:35 PM:

    " exactly my point. now they have the burden of proof that she knew about it.
    if she truly knew about it, then there would be an issue, but if she did not, the outcome would be completely different.
    how does one prove knowledge of an act? the best defense is the 5th amendment, and the miranda right to silence "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Oct 24, 2008 12:00 PM:

    " USAF SGT...ah yes. How ironic that this political candy (Palin) reminds us of another sweet. Oh how I despised her, but oh I loved her striding so proudly up on that horse. Ride on girl, ride on. Had to go and Google the image up again just for old times sake. Thanks for the memory. "

    moreofsame wrote on Oct 24, 2008 10:34 AM:

    " jp, if you committed a crime and your wife either helped or watched you do it, wouldn't she be arrested as an accessory?

    blackdog, if you don't think it is okay to have troopers like that, you should be mad that Palin didn't expend her efforts to change the investigative process and punishment for all future offenses for ALL troopers. The personal vendetta would only have removed one trooper for past offenses, done nothing to prevent future abuse, and likely cost the state a big wrongful termination suit. At best, she lacks judgement. "

    blackdog wrote on Oct 24, 2008 9:48 AM:

    " She fired Monegan for not reeling in a nut job officer who had 1 used departmental records for personal uses as a probationary officer, making death threats on Palin's father, 3 a criminal hunting violation, 4, public consumption of alcohol while driving a marked cop car, 5 unlawful steroid use, 6 tazering a minor, but instead keeping him on the force, for the "morale" of the cops. How should the fact that one of those instances involved a family member be construed as an abuse of power? Do we think it's OK to have Troopers like that? "

    jp wrote on Oct 24, 2008 9:33 AM:

    " palin is getting the blame for something her husband did?
    i don't understand this, if i committed a crime, would my wife be jailed instead of me? just because she did not stop me from doing it?
    i'll stick to supporting my community first, and when we feel like we can help someone else, we'll wait till they ask for help.
    but until then, we'll mind our own business. "

    USAF SGT wrote on Oct 24, 2008 7:51 AM:

    " A poll of 500? I realize there are more moose than people up there but what kind of poll is that? Less than 1/10th of 1 percent? With 82 from her home area. I live in Florida and saw the closest thing to SarahPalin. Katherine Harris let her head get too big because of national attention. Ms. Harris stole the 2000 election for Dubya, was not content with the GOP bone of U.S. Rep. she was tossed. Wanted the Senate. She could not have it as the GOP would not back her. LOST. Never hear her name now! "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Oct 24, 2008 7:35 AM:

    " Ohio...I'm not sure your "special needs" focused Gov would appreciate your term "lib'tards."

    RE our efforts "backfiring" -Polls continue to show McCain/Palin fading fast since Palin was picked (See PA in particular). NY Times endorsed Obama today. So too did former Bushie Scott McClellan. Both may not surprise, but the point is McCain is getting NO major endorsements. None. Don't blame liberal media for not reporting something either. Even Fox news has nothing. Nobody wants to hitch themselves to this campaign in free fall. Yer done baby. "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Oct 24, 2008 7:28 AM:

    " Why is this titled "Troopergate doesn't faze Palin approval rating." I would argue a drop of 18 points from 82 to 64 in a matter of weeks IS significant. Instead of cheering a local hero on the national stage, Troopergate has contributed to a nearly at 22% rating drop. How is that "not fazed." "

    Dont think so Ohio wrote on Oct 24, 2008 7:15 AM:

    " Ohio, have you seen Wooten? He is 6'5 290 pounds. I will pay to see Todd try and kick his butt. Now that is a make over the GOP couldn't afford. Go back to tending to your farm Ohio. "

    Brandi wrote on Oct 24, 2008 12:03 AM:

    " NO!!!!!!!! Gov. Palin did not abuse her authority. She can fire any body she wants this is a right to work state.
    ANY WAY EVERYONE JUST NEEDS TO GET OVER IT. She did everything just fine it seems to be no one is going to be happy unless they can get her for something. All of you need to get a life and leave Sarah Palins alone!!! "

    Brandi wrote on Oct 23, 2008 11:57 PM:

    " I feel very sorry for those of you out there voting for oboma and bin. YOU think this country is failing now. Belive it or not Mccain and Palin are both better suited for this kind of job. "

    LAURA wrote on Oct 23, 2008 11:08 PM:

    " OHIO
    I DONT KNOW WHAT PLANET YOUR ON BUT WATCH THE NEWS, OBAMAS KICKING MCCAINS BUTT. "

    Real Alaskan wrote on Oct 23, 2008 10:52 PM:

    " Hey Ohio get your head out of McCain and Palins rump. If you had taken the time to read the report you would see she did have authority to fire the commissioner, but she and her staff did abuse her power. Therefore she was guilty of what the investigation set out to investigate. Read it. Secondly You say she offered him a new job. This is true but within a week Palin and her idiotic truth squad claim he was fired. Which is it. New job or fired? see a side of Palin you don't and it is dishonest. "

    Ohio wrote on Oct 23, 2008 10:27 PM:

    " Another smear campaign foiled, She did nothing wrong, She offered him another job {cleaning the toilets} he declined......Todd should have just kicked Wootens butt, instead of asking a wussy to fire him....The Lib'tards will try anything to gain power, but it's all backfiring. Poor little Lib'tards "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage