It’s time for some realism regarding climate change

By Rep. Carl Gatto
Spectrum
Published on Thursday, March 19, 2009 11:29 PM AKDT

Last week 700 scientists, economists and public policy experts from 20 countries met in New York City. They concluded that global warming, if it is occurring at all, is probably natural rather than man-made, something very different from Al Gore’s message. Gore claims a calamity is occurring, and in 10 years the atmosphere may suffer irreversible harm. Both Gore and President Obama offer their solution: cap the production of energy from fossil fuels, tax carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, create a “cap and tax” bureaucracy, make most forms of energy very expensive, and transfer our personal wealth to government wealth — all to perform an absolutely worthless and unnecessary task.

The Gore-Obama plan is to collect CO2 from the atmosphere and store it underground forever. In return, we get little, except for the $645 billion in additional taxes, something that all Americans will pay every time they buy a product or fill up the tank of their car or truck.

Global warming alarmists want us to believe the temperature of Earth would stay the same year after year, century after century, if not for “the human presence.” This is scientifically false. Huge climate changes have occurred before humans could possibly have played a role. More recently, global temperatures rose from 1900 to 1940 (1934 was the century’s warmest year), fell from 1940 to 1975, rose again from 1975 to 1998, and declined from 1998 to 2008. How does “the human presence” account for this variation? It can’t.

Al Gore says “soaring global temperatures will bring human civilization to a screeching halt.”

“Global warmers” also predict no more agriculture in California and in 10 years the oceans will be toxic and all life could die. And yet, we’re halfway to the much-feared “doubling of CO2” in the atmosphere, and none of these disasters has even begun to appear.

Global warming’s true believers say trains carrying coal and other fuel to cities are really death trains carrying poisonous fuel to “coal-fired factories of death.” Whew, Hollywood horror films couldn’t top this stuff. But there’s more: hurricanes, melting polar ice caps, polar bear extinctions, dust bowls and anything else about the weather than you can imagine.

Let’s look at the facts.

Nearly 85 percent of U.S. energy consumption is carbon-based, and reducing that figure by using wind, solar and other renewable sources will take a long time, be very expensive and may not be technically possible. Scientists (and farmers) know carbon dioxide is not a “pollutant.” The vast majority of it is produced from natural sources, not human activities, and plants and forests use CO2 to grow and produce oxygen for all living things.

Ordinary air contains roughly 78.08 percent nitrogen, 20.95 percent oxygen, 0.93 percent argon and a paltry 0.038 percent carbon dioxide. Scientists — including several who presented at the New York conference — are quite unsure that a tiny increase in that tiny amount of CO2 is having any effect on climate. Many scientists believe negative feedbacks more than offset whatever warming the CO2 might be capable of causing.

Our whole solar system is showing climate changes, including the climates of Mars, Saturn, Jupiter and even lonely Pluto. What all the planets have in common, though, is that they receive heat from the sun and they are affected by cosmic rays and other galaxy-wide processes. Nothing we do can compare to changes in sun-spot activity and brightness when it comes to changing our climate.

Our climate appears to be once again reversing course and cooling, repeating a cycle that has repeated itself thousands of times in the past. Glaciers advance when the earth cools, then make up for all that work by retreating when the earth re-warms. Human activities may have a little impact, but is it good or bad? Worth preventing? No one knows.

So for the time being, let’s accept that the earth’s climate has been wide-ranging for 5 billion years. That’s our planet’s history, and we are here in spite of (or maybe because of) all those changes.

Thank God for that.

Carl Gatto of Palmer represents the 13th District in the Alaska Legislature. He can be reached at Representative_Carl_Gatto@legis.state.ak.us.

 

Comments

32 comment(s)

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Apr 1, 2009 5:33 PM:

    " KATT DOB=68 for those wondering if I remember the '70's or tripped my way thru them.

    I think we need 2 balance appreciation of your experience w/ understanding that there's value in new thinking as well. And there is value in both.

    Focusing back on climate change, I'm aware of the arguement for cooling in the 70's. That's 35 years ago. Science & technology have rolled forward greatly in the interim. I think you need to look at the new information in that context. We are perfecting our understanding. "

    Read the scientific facts wrote on Mar 30, 2009 7:30 PM:

    " It has been PROVEN recently that the world is now cooling down. Global warming as you call it is NATURE taking its course. All you tree huggers need to LEAVE Alaska.......NOW "

    jp to northern dave wrote on Mar 30, 2009 12:57 PM:

    " my bet would be that maxx was maxed out on psychodelics, and lot's-o-weed.

    You see, Maxx is like all the tree huggers, save the world, but hand-outs make the world go-round.

    Ha! maxx, i had to do it! "

    northern dave wrote on Mar 30, 2009 8:48 AM:

    " To Ben C;
    Maxx probably can't remember that. Judging my his blogs, I'd say he wasn't born yet back then. "

    Spankles wrote on Mar 29, 2009 6:31 PM:

    " Mt Redoubt probably did more damage the atmosphere than we did. MAXX is probably a volcano hugger too. "

    Ben C wrote on Mar 29, 2009 12:30 PM:

    " Does anybody else remember the '70s when we were all subjected to similar brainwashing only it was global COOLING we were being told was the harbinger of doom? The scientists and such all proved that the world was cooling and we were entering another ice age? WOW! Those amazing greenies and thier know-it-all research have somehow said that in the span of just a few decades, we have went from global cooling to global warming but both are due to the same reasons! "

    Brett M wrote on Mar 29, 2009 7:04 AM:

    " I hope ALGORE and the others are right.
    4 more feet of ocean and I won't have to wait to launch my boat at low tide anymore.
    10 degrees warmer every day as we're nearing the end of a long dark cold winter sounds good too.
    Looks like we picked the right place to live, but don't toss your arctic gear just yet. It wasn't so long ago that it took a bunch of tired sailors to point out to all the genius's that the horizon is curved because the earth is round. "

    jp wrote on Mar 28, 2009 1:51 PM:

    " it's all marketing, dreamed up by Conglomerates, emphisized by blind tree huggers, making it possible to capitolize on the new "Green" marketing strategy.

    nothing more. "

    Joe Zelinski wrote on Mar 27, 2009 7:47 PM:

    " The ICECAP groups is not a science based group but a political organization. They do not do their own studies but piece together bits from other studies to support an agenda. This happens in other groups supporting golbal warming as well. There are org's that are pretty much neutral like the Line Offices of the NOAA where raw data is available for you to study and make up your own mind. To understand the data you will need a pretty strong background in math, chemistry, physics and statistics. But even without that a lot can be understood. "

    Broomhilda wrote on Mar 27, 2009 3:10 PM:

    " Global Warming is now Climate Change. War on Terror is now Overseas Contingency Operation. I will say it again. If I had the brains to invent this bunch of B.S. about global warming I would be laughing ALL THE WAY TO THE BANK!!! Anyway, it's nice to know that more people are realizing what a farce people like Gore (and soon, Obama) and their beliefs are. "

    To Ben C... wrote on Mar 27, 2009 9:43 AM:

    " "Still, there's no denying that curbing the amount we pollute into the atmosphere can only be beneficial."

    Seems to me there is nothing else that really needs to be said on this issue. "

    jp wrote on Mar 27, 2009 8:24 AM:

    " yeah maxx, i find it amusing that anyone would listen to, or act on anything that lying, deceitful Osama says, or puts forth.
    now they're talking a sales tax nationwide.
    impeach this dipsheizer now, but it may already be too late. "

    Dennis O. wrote on Mar 27, 2009 2:44 AM:

    " Way to go Carl. The warmists have been allowed to spew their nonsense for years without challenge. The tables are finally turning and people are seeing for themselves what a hoax the climate change movement has brought us. Stand strong on this Carl .. don't let the hoaxters get you down! "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Mar 26, 2009 11:50 AM:

    " To JP...regarding trees within 100 miles..that's true...especially if they have knot holes. :-)

    You must be going crazy JP. Every time you click the remote you've got Obama on another channel. 60 minutes, Jay Leno, the Wash Wizzard Game. I'll bet any day now you go Elvis on your set and put a bullet in it. "

    poor Jim is at it again... wrote on Mar 26, 2009 11:46 AM:

    " Silly liberal...it has to be one OR the other with you small-minded people, doesn't it. Here's an even better idea...you develope alternative energy WHILE STILL taking advantage of what we have now so you can ease from one to the other! But not to idiot greenies! They think it makes sense to stop one before the other one is ready to go! Kind of like letting go of one vine before you have your hand on the other! "

    Jim from Boston wrote on Mar 26, 2009 8:12 AM:

    " Drill Baby Drill !!!

    Drill like there's no tomorrow and there may not be.

    Why not invest in alternatives? What's the worst that can happen. We employ people and develop useful technologies. The net cost is probably not large and we may likely profit.

    Seems a smart hedge for the possibility that the deniers are wrong. "

    jp wrote on Mar 24, 2009 4:02 PM:

    " and one more thing about maxx that he didn't mention;

    If there's a tree within 100 miles, he'll hug it!

    just messin with ya maxx :-) "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Mar 24, 2009 1:42 PM:

    " Uncle Jed... I am weird...but I think some of "my" posts that are confounding you may be by my shadow imposter poster. (I am honored ot have one.)

    Here's a user guide for you. If the post is witty, adds value/understanding, introduces content from a qualilty 3rd party source, and is sufficiently snarky...it's the real KATT.

    If it's dopey...it's the other guy. "

    jp wrote on Mar 24, 2009 8:35 AM:

    " I look at it this way;

    We humans are like hoards of locusts, we are the predator, the "infestation" as it will, we only are driven by one thing, that being greed. We will most assuredly be responsible for our own demise.
    There is no way around it. Deal with it, and make the best of it. "

    To tim wrote on Mar 23, 2009 8:02 PM:

    " Funny thing about the dark ages; most people were illiterate and had to believe whatever they were told. What's your excuse? "

    tim wrote on Mar 22, 2009 8:46 PM:

    " Way to push us back into the dark ages Carl. Do you really believe what you wrote or are you getting a campaign contribution for it? "

    Thank God wrote on Mar 22, 2009 3:30 AM:

    " I wish your column could be disseminated to all of the brainless so-called "mainstream media" morons who keep spouting the Chicken Little garbage.

    Anthropogenic global warming is a complete and total fraud. You have morons like Obama who want to use such a flawed theory to raise trillions of dollars in indirect taxation and the lying "scientists" who get their grants paid for by the same moron. It's a huge Ponzi scheme which is utterly despicable. "

    Uncle Jed to MAXKATT wrote on Mar 21, 2009 9:27 PM:

    " Your brain is weird. You are wrong about everything. You are a threat to logic. You are a confused follower. Don't try to freak out Alaskans with your messed up thoughts. "

    MaxKatt Wannabe wrote on Mar 21, 2009 5:42 PM:

    " Yes, I wanna be just like you, MaxKatt.

    I've read several of your comments regarding various topics, and you're my new hero!

    From now on I'll join you in swallowing every pill the gov't tells me to, even if it's a really bad one.

    I know! Let's get some shirts with the letter L for lemming...And can I hold your hand so we can go off Obama's cliff together?

    Talk to ya later new buddy! "

    northern dave wrote on Mar 21, 2009 10:24 AM:

    " Also, how come the fact is conveniently omitted that nearly every scientist or group that reports all the evidence of global warming is PAID by environmentalist groups? When you look at the truly indepedent studies, you get results all over the board that state, year after year, that global warming is 'inconclusive' based on the date. Of course, THOSE studies are never discussed or introduced by Gore or any of the high-dollar, green-funded groups. It's kind of like the media...society is spoon-fed a sliver of slanted information to support the presenter's point of view. "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Mar 20, 2009 5:54 PM:

    " Mike- They Copenhagen group does seem to indicate man has an impact.

    "The group called on policy-makers to use all tools available to reduce dangerous emissions of greenhouse gases." "

    for sure wrote on Mar 20, 2009 12:05 PM:

    " Sheesh. Maxkatt from NY. Whatever. This is the young un from that cesspool known as new york that thinks Alaska is nothing but flat frozen tundra with people living in igloos, polar bears, etc. Was all suprised that we grow vegetables up here (yes, I saw and snickered at that post too). Maybe he believes in the global warming brainwashing because the smell of rotting corpses in the alleys is stronger than usual this year. "

    northern dave wrote on Mar 20, 2009 11:50 AM:

    " How come when loony-tune Gore and the rest of the 'feel-good' pack talk about changes in the environment, they don't talk about the number of glaciers that are GROWING in size (just as many as are shrinking)? Those areas in the world that are reporting either no change in average temp or LOWER temps? That ice shelves have been breaking off Antartica and then re-growing for millions of years? How come they only show a sliver of science that supports thier opinion vs. the equal amounts of science that doesn't support thier warm, fuzzy 'mother earth' bunk? "

    Mike wrote on Mar 20, 2009 11:43 AM:

    " If you read the CNN piece max references it doesn't say a thing about man's ability to affect the changes one way or the other. Could it be that the mainstream environmental wackos have realized that horse is dead?
    Mike "

    allen wrote on Mar 20, 2009 10:12 AM:

    " Carl's thoughtful piece holds more sway for me than MAX from NY. The NY guy doesn't even know we can grow our own food in Alaska (see earlier post). How's that for science and knowledge? "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Mar 20, 2009 7:26 AM:

    " I think I'll continue 2 side w/ scientists who have spent their lives studying this vs. local pol who ends his note w/ reference 2 God.

    Given conclussion the group of 700 in NY came to I'm going to guess they were heavy on the policy & economist guys, & light on scientists.

    Ironically, this same week, (3/13/9) CNN reported a group of SCIENTISTS more than twice as large (2,000 researchers) as the NY group met in Copenhagen & reached a much different conclussion:

    http://www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/europe/03/12/irreversible.climate/ "

    Ben C wrote on Mar 20, 2009 1:04 AM:

    " The Earth has been warming and cooling for millions of years. Only human arrogance assumes that it only does so now because of us. The amount of carbon in the atmosphere sounds impressive when given in number of tons. But if looked at another way; if the atmosphere was represented as a football field, the amount of carbon would measure 1/2" of the white stripe at the endzone. Still, there's no denying that curbing the amount we pollute into the atmosphere can only be beneficial. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   




Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage