New board puts Metiva on leave

By Todd L. Disher
Frontiersman
Published on Thursday, May 28, 2009 7:05 PM AKDT

WASILLA — An additional board member resigned and six new members were appointed to the Greater Wasilla Chamber of Commerce board of directors after executive director Cheryl Metiva requested administrative leave Tuesday.

Metiva began the chamber’s first meeting since five of the seven directors resigned by reading a statement she previously released to the media. In it she said she resolved previous credit card charges with the past president and did not have an opportunity to address the current board’s concerns about her expenditures. She looks forward to an audit and the opportunity to explain any matters in question.

Metiva requested administrative leave in order to best serve the audit process, she said, and will remain fully available to auditor. She did not want to make any other statement now and concluded by saying it was a privilege serving the chamber for the last five years.

In a press release issued Thursday, the new board of directors said Metiva has been placed on paid administrative leave for the three weeks she is entitled to under her vacation policy. After the three weeks, she will remain on unpaid leave pending the completion of the third party audit. The board will decide whether to retain Metiva based on the results of the audit. If she is retained, she will be reimbursed for the period of her unpaid leave.

After Metiva read her statement, Chas St. George, one of the two board members remaining, read his own statement at Tuesday’s meeting. He said he came on after the board had already made discoveries about Metiva’s expenditures and advocated for a third-party audit from the beginning. The chamber deserves a complete and unbiased assessment about its well-being, he said. Because of doubts about his impartiality and in order to avoid any perception he would impede a fair investigation, he tendered his resignation effective immediately.

Quentin Algood, the last remaining board member at this point, said she was at a number of meetings where there were suggested and hinted and failed accusations, but she had never seen any indication the law was broken.

It’s clear a third-party audit needed to be done, she said, but the chamber needed a board of directors before any action could be taken. There is nothing in the by-laws about what to do in a situation like this, she said, but she is willing to do what the members want.

St. George said the chamber needed to move toward filling the board of directors because they are currently not in compliance with their by-laws. A membership quorum was possible at Tuesday’s meeting because there was at least 10 percent of the 328 members in attendance.

A motion was made and passed to call for an emergency election. Volunteers to serve on the board were called for, and six people stood up. There was then a motion introduced to have Algood appoint one new member, have those two appoint a third, the three appoint a fourth and so on until the board was full of seven directors.

Mike Gabel was the first volunteer to be appointed. He is the Wasilla branch manager for United Rentals and has served on the board in the past. Marcus Reum — the second appointee — works for Country Financial and was the vice chair of the Economic Enterprise committee for the chamber in 2008. He said he is friends with both the Metivas and the five directors who resigned, so members can judge his bias as they may.

Next came Wal-Mart employee Chris Abernathy. He said he moved to Wasilla from North Carolina just eight months ago, and he doesn’t know any of the parties involved. David Baker was appointed fourth. He works for Wells Fargo and said he has only been in the Valley for a year. The board then selected Rizz Arbelovsky, the owner of Nails Plus. Julie Busch, co-owner of Buschwacker Decoys and president of the Mat-Su Anglers Club, rounded out the now-complete board of seven directors.

The new directors will sit on the board only until new members are selected during the regularly scheduled election in November. The board has selected Abernathy as the new president.

The statement released Thursday also said the new board members are getting quotes for an independent third party audit. How the chamber will pay for the audit will be determined once the cost and time frame are pinned down, Abernathy said.

Assistant Director Lyn Carden has agreed to act as the interim executive director. She is on vacation until Wednesday, and the chamber office has been staffed by volunteers from the at-large membership.

“We are going to try and continue business as usual,” Abernathy said when asked if the scheduled events like the Silver Salmon Derby are going to happen this year.

The next board meeting is Monday at 5:15 p.m. at the chamber office in the Wasilla train depot. It is open to the membership.

While not present at Tuesday’s meeting, Marty Metiva released a statement of his own. He said the Wasilla chamber has been a recipient of the Polar Plunge fundraiser in the past. The check the chamber received from the Plunge was a donation to help the chamber with their budget shortfall and preceded any allegations about the executive director, he said. He concluded by saying he overreacted to the board’s decision to split the money between the non-profits the 2009 Plunge supported, taking their response personally rather than professionally.

Contact Todd L. Disher at todd.disher@frontiersman.com or (907) 352-2252.

Comments

30 comment(s)

    2 comments wrote on Jun 9, 2009 4:19 PM:

    " #1 not all medical insurance covers messages.
    #2 regardless of the shape they are in Cheryl should be required to hand over EVERYTHING she bought with Chamber money. Dresses, shoes, what ever and then it should all be donated to charity. After that how about pressing some charges and nailing her (blank) to the wall! I wonder how Ms. Metiva looks in orange? I guess it doesn't matter because I don't care! Let's get them before they skip town and we all know why WILL skip town. History repeats itself. "

    Georgia wrote on Jun 5, 2009 11:38 PM:

    " To Puleeeeze,

    Yes I am on my important husbands medical insurance...thank you for asking! Although that really had nothing to do with the comment "

    Not shocked wrote on Jun 5, 2009 6:02 PM:

    " How much money did Cheryl get from City funds for the tourism center? $12,500 and that was a bonus she gave herself without board permission. How many trips, meals and hotels did Cheryl use City money for claiming it was for the tourism center? All you have to do is ask the City Clerk's office for copies of all reports from the Chamber on the tourism funds. Then you can make up your mind just how guilty she is of misappropriation of tax funds. I surprised the Frontiersman hasn't checked out this fantastic lead for a headline! It's all true! "

    Oh Puleeeeze wrote on Jun 4, 2009 6:31 PM:

    " Georgia,
    It sounds like you do need a massage since you are living as a martyr! Again people, you have no idea what has happened and we won't know until the audit has been done and questions answered. Oh and Georgia, I bet YOU have health insurance from your very important businessman! "

    Georgia wrote on Jun 4, 2009 8:36 AM:

    " This was membership money that was not supposed to be used or authorized for use on an E.D.'s wanna be lavish lifestyle. I work 60 hrs a week in a high stress job for a very accomplished, successful business and am in need of a massage every couple of weeks (which I get and pay for MYSELF). NOW your telling me all I need to do is work for the chamber! Can someone please let the readers know where to apply for this vacant position. "

    Small Towns wrote on Jun 4, 2009 8:07 AM:

    " Interesting how people always talk about small towns standing up for each other. The majority of these comments lay that idea to rest. Many people on hear sound like they are a bit jaded, maybe have some personal beef to settle and cowardly hide behind to their screens. "

    to right hand gal not anymore wrote on Jun 2, 2009 9:25 AM:

    " Once I read your comment" We will just put it on the chamber, I deserve it!" , I have to say I have also heard this a few times . Wow when the truth comes out by so many people it really hurts, just ask the Metivas they have not been seen in church or around town since Cherly ran in gave her speach and ran out. "

    2 for 1 wrote on May 31, 2009 10:21 PM:

    " See if you can get an audit for the other non-profit in the Valley with no scruples - The Alaska Avalanche. Don't look for meeting minutes, because they don't hold board meetings or membership meetings. Who is their Board Treasurer? I'd be worried if I were you since you can be held liable when youth hockey funds are used for Jr. Hockey expenses. Mayor Rupright, are you listening?? "

    Take our Community Back wrote on May 31, 2009 7:08 PM:

    " Public Service: Are you there for the right reasons? I am really tired of reading these headlines. Wasilla, Alaska: Home of Boss Hogg Palin and all of Her Cronies. It's way past the stage of embarrassing. "

    Right hand gal NOT ANY MORE wrote on May 31, 2009 5:00 PM:

    " With out saying who I am, lets just say I used to be in an office 10 feet away from Cheryl every day. I was the one who realized something wasn't right about a year and a half ago. She was my best "PAL" and in about 2.3 seconds she hated my guts. The accountability was rediculous. That credit card was used for shoes, dresses, expensive dinners and I was witness to it all. Just one quote from Cheryls mouth out of the million plus "We will just put it on the chamber, I deserve it!" "

    Nancy wrote on May 31, 2009 4:12 PM:

    " So many people seem to jump to conclusions ... the condos are being painted, which is why there are no names on the buildings. I was at the Polar Plunge, and the Wasilla Chamber was listed as one of the recipients. Before you all assume that Cheryl did something wrong, at least wait until the audit.
    None of us is perfect. Everyone makes mistakes, even good people.
    Why not wait until you have all the facts to make judgment? "

    Smells bad wrote on May 31, 2009 8:32 AM:

    " Not only is it the business Q Algood owns but it is the same business that does the Chamber's website, Marty Metiva for Mayor website, RC&D (Marty Metiva's employer) website, the Wasilla Tourism Bureau website (ran by Cheryl Metiva). Is anyone starting to smell something here? "

    No Money for Wasilla wrote on May 31, 2009 8:22 AM:

    " Good point. Keep in mind that ITS Alaska is owned by Algood who was on the chamber board and a proponent of Metiva. I wonder how many other of the new members are loyal friends of Metiva? Until this is fixed, not one dime of my paycheck will be spent with Wasilla businesses. Fix it, restore faith and we will come back. Until then, it's a loss of revenue. "

    REAL DEAL wrote on May 30, 2009 6:29 PM:

    " I AM GLAD TO HEAR THAT LYN IS GOING TO BE THE INTERIM ED...I SINCERELY HOPE THE NEW BOARD FOLLOWS THROUGHT WITH THE AUDIT-THEY ARE A GOOD GROUP OF PEOPLE THAT JUST NEED TO MAKE SURE THE AUDIT IS DONE AND THE MEMBBERS KNOW THE TRUTH-THEY DESERVE TO KNOW! "

    Rizz is Metivas nail lady wrote on May 30, 2009 6:29 PM:

    " It that a joke, her nail lady becomes her superior!! HAHAHA Betcha its the appoint the good old friends like Sara scenario. "

    REAL DEAL wrote on May 29, 2009 9:54 PM:

    " I AM GLAD TO HEAR THAT LYN IS GOING TO BE THE INTERIM ED...I SINCERELY HOPE THE NEW BOARD FOLLOWS THROUGHT WITH THE AUDIT-THEY ARE A GOOD GROUP OF PEOPLE THAT JUST NEED TO MAKE SURE THE AUDIT IS DONE AND THE MEMBBERS KNOW THE TRUTH-THEY DESERVE TO KNOW! "

    Stop Them wrote on May 29, 2009 8:31 PM:

    " I find it ironic that ITS Alaska developed the website for Metiva's Chamber, Metiva's Tourism Bureau funded by the City, Metiva's RC&D website which is Marty's job, and Metiva's campaign for mayor website. Couple this with the fact that St. George was Metiva's endorsers and Algood was the treasurer for Metiva's run for mayor. This is way too cozy and too much intermingling of funds to feel comfortable. These people clearly have no values or conscious issues throwing money around like this. Marty and Cheryl should be stopped before they sneek out of town like theives in thenight. "

    Newspaper Headline is misleading wrote on May 29, 2009 5:49 PM:

    " The headline

    "New board puts Metiva on leave" is misleading.

    Before the new board was selected Cheryl, on her own, had ***already*** requested administrative leave.

    I trust the new board will get the chamber back on track and decide wether or not to retain Cheryl.

    The chamber will survive and hopefully flourish.

    It is very sad that Cheryl is being held accountable for Marty's action.

    Today, women should be held accountable for their own actions and not be held liable for their husbands.

    20 year WCC member. "

    you call yourself fair wrote on May 29, 2009 2:38 PM:

    " to you call yourself fair...

    SORRY let me guess is this Cheryl , Marty or Quinton Algood.....Gotcha "

    you call yourself fair wrote on May 29, 2009 2:19 PM:

    " To In All Fairness,
    fair to whom? if you are as all knowing as you purport to be, you would know that the condos are being painted and that all of the name signs have been taken down. and, if you cared at all to be fair, you too will wait for the audit. "

    Minding The Store wrote on May 29, 2009 2:18 PM:

    " Did the Chamber relieve Cheryl of the credit card whilst she is on vacation? "

    I agree wrote on May 29, 2009 12:31 PM:

    " Go Lynn. She has been the go to person at the GWCC. If you wanted something done , other then spending member funds you would ask Lynn. "

    Moving on wrote on May 29, 2009 11:41 AM:

    " Let the audit do the talking and in the mean time, GWCC members put your faith in Lyn, the interim ED! Give her the support to bring you out of this mess Cheryl has caused. She has been the go to person for the GWCC if you want something done and I can honestly say that she has been the glue to keep the chamber functioning! I will be excited when they take the "interim" from her title!! "

    oh well wrote on May 29, 2009 11:23 AM:

    " If they run , better for us its over and we can move on. It will suck we get nothing back, but they dont have anything to repay the chamber with anyways. "

    In all fairness wrote on May 29, 2009 10:43 AM:

    " I completely agree that Cheryl Metiva should be fired but they do need to pay her out her vacation time, which is basically what the administrative leave is. This is why it ends in three weeks.

    My guess is the Metiva's will have skipped town by that point, though. I drove by their house and their name plate sign has been taken down and there are boxes sitting outside. My bet is they're looking for the next unsuspecting town to prey on. I only hope that those future organizations do better background checks on these crooks. "

    Tom wrote on May 29, 2009 10:15 AM:

    " Heck I ws there , I thought she put herself on this admin leave/paid vacation. "

    what a ripoff wrote on May 29, 2009 8:44 AM:

    " to another audit

    Of course he did not disclosed to Polar Plunge sponsors and donors that the Chamber would be receiving a portion of the event proceeds prior to their participation Answer this one did Cheryl tell the chamber members she was riping them off. I also want to say the 100.000 the chamber recieved , why did the first check out of that go to Cheryl, for like 10,000 or was it 12,000. What a stinking rip. Lets pay her more. "

    what a ripoff wrote on May 29, 2009 8:10 AM:

    " This is crap we got ripped off and then we are going to pay 3 weeks for nothing. Good choice new board, I am ready not make a new board already. Why dont the new board pay her out of their own pockets. "

    Another audit needed wrote on May 29, 2009 7:35 AM:

    " Good for Marty Metiva for publicly stating he overreacted.

    However, I am concerned about his statement that the Wasilla Chamber "has been a recipient of the Polar Plunge fundraiser in the past." Was it disclosed to the Polar Plunge sponsors and donors that the Chamber would be receiving a portion of the event proceeds prior to their participation? Was the Chamber board made aware of those past contributions when they were received?

    I'd appreciate an answer if anyone knows. "

    Whatever you say Marty.. wrote on May 28, 2009 9:14 PM:

    " "...taking their response personally rather than professionally."...for the good of all members, the city and even the state will the Metivas please leave. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   




Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage