Cat survives snare; owner wants answers

BY TODD L. DISHER
Frontiersman
Published on Saturday, June 20, 2009 7:12 PM AKDT

WASILLA — A cat named Henry served as the latest reminder of the tension between country and city.

Last weekend, Kelly Bennett could not find Henry. With the memory of the cat she never found last summer still fresh in her mind, Bennett was worried.

Monday morning when she was getting ready for work, Bennett heard Henry come in the back door of her house in the Forest Hills subdivision off Palmer-Fishhook Road.

(Use arrows above to view more photos)

Henry was screaming like a hyena.

When he turned sideways to her, Bennett saw a wire tearing into Henry’s abdomen. She tried to cut it off with her wire cutters, but the wire was too tight to fit the blade underneath.

She rushed him to All Creatures Veterinary Hospital. Henry went into surgery and came out stitched up with four drainage tubes and dosed heavily on antibiotics and pain medications. Bennett said Friday that she was taking Henry in that day to have the tubes removed and get a progress report on his recovery.

“The doctors said he shouldn’t be alive,” Bennett said. “He looks like he’s two pieces sewn together.”

The doctors also told Bennett the wire was the snare from a trap. The vet said it is impossible for the snare to come lose on itself, so someone must have cut the cat from the trap without removing the wire, Bennett said.

She turned the snare, pictures of Henry pre- and post-surgery and bill from her vet — $686 — in to the State Wildlife Troopers.

Tory Oleck, detachment commander for the wildlife troopers, said his office in Palmer sees cases like this once or twice every year. While he could not say if trapping was legal or not in this particular area of Palmer, trapping season is most definitely closed.

Illegally placed traps are can bring with them a fine of up to $10,000 and a year in jail, Oleck said. If the trap catches a pet, and the investigation determines it was an accident, his department still holds the trapper accountable. If it is determined to be intentional, it is ruled as a destruction of private property and is no different than shooting it with a gun.

Bop Haskell, chief animal control officer for the borough, said there is an ordinance against trapping domestic animals.

He said he sent an officer to Bennett’s neighborhood to check for the snare, but admitted, “That’s like looking for a needle in a haystack.”

Haskell has only held his job since November, but he said this is the first incident of snaring he’s heard about.

He also said animal control has live traps people can use if they want to trap a nuisance animal.

As for Henry, he is being nursed back to health by Bennett who is expecting he will have a full recovery.

“I don’t know anybody is intentionally doing this, but this is my second cat,” Bennett said. “To think that people even do this to animals is sick. It’s a horrible way to die.” She said everyone she has talked to in her neighborhood is livid. “There are children and grandchildren who play here.”

Contact Todd L. Disher at todd.disher@frontiersman.com or 352-2252.

Comments

36 comment(s)

    Power Wagon wrote on Jul 2, 2009 1:21 PM:

    " Last time I checked, there's no law requiring me to LIKE cats. For whatever reason I wish, I don't have to tolerate them on my property. Just like you have the right to not like dogs or not want my dogs on your property. Try to grow up, pull up your big-boy pants and learn a little accountability. Don't want something happening to your cat? Keep it on your own property. "

    Again y0u assume that the cat was trapped close by wrote on Jul 2, 2009 6:49 AM:

    " Since the cat was allowed to roam, as many irresponsible cat owners allow, then you have no way to know how far away that trap was. Could have been miles away. Plain and simple, keep your cat home. That is the best option for all. I don't like cats and should not have to put up with yours making a mess out of my chicken coop and killing the chicks. And don't kid yourself. Your cat kills regularly and they are the only animal that kills for the fun of it. "

    to smarter...than the cat wrote on Jun 30, 2009 6:27 PM:

    " Shooting my dog in your yard wouldn't 'fly'? Actually, it would 'fly'...because it's LEGAL! Would we like it? No! But that doesn't matter! The law says you can do it so I guess it's our obligation to keep our dogs out of your yard! My god...does ANYBODY hold themselves accountable anymore? "

    Smarter than you.... wrote on Jun 30, 2009 3:46 PM:

    " Bottom line, using traps and snares isn't exclusive to native americans so whoever argued that one (and there was more than one) is just way off-base. The fact that this is a subdivision, where families and children live is what makes this situation dangerous, whether you like cats or not. How is this trap issue any different from me shooting your dog in my yard because I'm tired of it getting loose. All you dog lovers know that wouldn't fly either. So try to put yourself in this woman's shoes, if was your cat/dog/kid. "

    watcher wrote on Jun 30, 2009 3:19 PM:

    " ...as opposed to those who relieve themselves in alleys or in their pants after they pass out from the booze... "

    jp to palmer farm wrote on Jun 30, 2009 2:14 PM:

    " yes, that is correct.
    there were no problems before the white man.

    Have to question the antics of the white man, cooks outside, relieves himself inside........????? "

    Pegboard wrote on Jun 30, 2009 1:14 PM:

    " I have no inkling whatsoever how referring to white trash has anything to do with declaring original Native culture to "uncivilized."

    I suppose being civilized means whatever you want it to mean: being mannerly, following the Golden Rule, or it might mean a high tech, complicated society with a large population.

    I like to think it means, at the very least, thinking before you shoot a stray cat. A very different society on the other side of the world developed the concept of Karma: so, dude, remember, what goes around, comes around. "

    Palmer Farm wrote on Jun 30, 2009 9:40 AM:

    " Yes indeed, all your problems are to be blamed on 'the white man'. You're not responsible in any way, shape or form. You can't be held accountable for your actions. It's all the fault of 'the white man', right? Forcing drugs and alcohol on you. Forcing you to turn your villages into virtual dumps. Yes, it's all the fault of 'the white man'. (Because before the 'white man' got here, all was peaceful and perfect! No wars, no rapes,...no, no..none of that until 'the white man' showed up!) HA HA!
    (All this from an article about a stupid cat!) "

    jp to pegboard wrote on Jun 30, 2009 8:19 AM:

    " nice white trash argument!
    but, i am an original american, so, i guess you weren't referring to me.
    You see, our people lived in harmony with nature for thousands of years, until the white man came here and "civilized" us. we had no problems with global warming, poisoning the earth with toxins, and defoliage. And poisoning our people with alcohol to bring their guard down so you could steal their land, "in the name of God"
    Gee , thanks for showing us how "un-civilized" we were. "

    Power Wagon wrote on Jun 29, 2009 3:39 PM:

    " Yeah, you seem like 'part cat' allright. A real....oh, nevermind. They won't print it if I say it anyway... "

    Pegboard wrote on Jun 29, 2009 3:15 PM:

    " JP:
    All the comments below remind me that in the mid-seventies during the pipeline construction boom, so many of the oil workers were so unpopular here that a common saying was, "Happiness is seeing a Texan heading south with an Okie under each arm."

    How times have changed! The middle class wanna be beauty queen governor pretends to be a redneck, and white trash are proud of that label. What is the world coming to?

    Jamie Love, where are you??? We need you back! "

    MAXKATT from NY wrote on Jun 29, 2009 1:13 PM:

    " Find the trapper, put his "equipment" in the snare. Let him howl.

    JP...We have established that I'm not gay, black, or jewish. I am, however, part cat, so please take care of my kind up there. ...and don't tell me I'm not a cat! I've got nine lives and always land on my feet. Meow! "

    neo-hippy wrote on Jun 29, 2009 8:40 AM:

    " Oh boo-hoo and sniff sniff! That poor little kitty! My heart weeps with the idea that some cute little bunny might get caught in it and I'll never be able to hug him! I miss my poor Southern California, where we all danced in our sandals and embraced mother earth alongside our animal friends! I'll light some incense tonight and do some deep meditating over the plight of your kitty cat!

    ..good lord... "

    Disgusted wrote on Jun 29, 2009 7:51 AM:

    " JP:
    I did move Outside after living in Paradise/Alaska for 33 years. I fought the good fight, but I was outnumbered. So I leave it to you and your ilk.
    If you want to keep on ruining Alaska like some spoiled rotten kid who cries foul everytime his least little wish is denied, go right ahead. And I hope you are happy with the inevitable results. But that won't happen! Your turn will come. You will finally understand what I have been trying to pound through your thick skulls. More people equals less rights for everybody! "

    Annie wrote on Jun 28, 2009 11:37 PM:

    " I am sorry to hear your cat suffered such terrible injuries.

    Thank you for alerting the community to the fact that some irresponsible, and heartless, people set out traps and snares that wildlife and children might stumble upon. "

    jp wrote on Jun 28, 2009 7:40 PM:

    " Proud to be Valley Trash!

    if you people don't like people like me, move back to california or colorado, as you may be a bit outnumbered. "

    Power Wagon wrote on Jun 28, 2009 11:53 AM:

    " Seems to me somebody DID find another way...he used snares! HA! "

    Disgusted wrote on Jun 28, 2009 8:15 AM:

    " I never said the guy shouldn't shoot the cat if that is the law. I was merely suggesting that there was a better way to handle the situation. Get a clue!

    When I first came to the Mat Su Valley in 1971, there were about 6000 people. As of 2000, there were 60,000. By my standards, that is horribly crowded. It's just not the same. You could look into the history of animal control in the Valley and find out that it got started because of too many angry shootings of strays in crowded neighborhoods that almost hit people. "

    Power Wagon wrote on Jun 27, 2009 2:53 PM:

    " the 'disgusted' blogger is always good for a quick laugh. Now he's using a stupid snared cat to somehow twist it into another political attack from his wierd, socialist point of view. Yes indeed folks, the law stating that you can shoot another animal on your property is a clear example of conservatism! HA HA! Oh, and I LOVE the reasoning that as Alaska becomes more 'crowded' (oh yes, we're SO populated here!) it's only right that we don't mind other people's animals wandering all over.
    I hope somebody's goat herd wanders onto this dimwit's porch...LOL! "

    jp wrote on Jun 27, 2009 1:10 PM:

    " there you go involving lawyers again.
    my way was quicker and had resolve in minutes, and didn't have to pay a lawyer or court costs.
    Those who let their cats run free are the cause of the infestation of feral cats, which are becoming a huge problem.
    so join the F.C.H.A ( feral cat hunting alliance) and do your part to protect nature. "

    Disgusted wrote on Jun 27, 2009 7:08 AM:

    " JP: the civilized thing to do would have been to have caught the cat, taken pictues of the damage, and then sued the owner of the cat for damages. Paying out money knocks sense into people; shooting their animals only breeds hatred and resentment even if the fault was theirs. Shooting the cat was definitely a white trash thing to do. We are not living in pioneer days anymore. If you conservatives want progress, then learn to live with the consequences of crowding and the nescessary laws that must be put in place to keep chaos at bay. "

    To JP wrote on Jun 26, 2009 8:23 PM:

    " YOU GO! How dare these city slickers move up here and tell us that we are trash? Those of us who have roughed it, survived the hard times and built this state? As for the lady and her STUPID cat.............Have you ever heard of the leash law? You want answers? Why don't you check out the leash laws, while you are flying back to California, Colorado or where ever you came from!!! We REAL Alaskans don't want you here! YOU GO JP!! There is a LEASH LAW!! "

    Power Wagon wrote on Jun 26, 2009 9:21 AM:

    " If your pet is on somebody else's property it's fair game folks. Sorry, but that's just the way it is. My property is fenced to keep my dogs in. But they've managed to get out a time or two. Would I be VERY upset if somebody shot one of my dogs on thier property? Sure I would. But I'd also recognize that it's my obligation to keep my dogs on my property. This lady seems like so many that isn't capable of being accountable. "

    Kitty wrote on Jun 25, 2009 2:36 PM:

    " Regarding JP - He is a perfect example of the Valley, at least the part that they call valley trash. We wondered where the valley got that name and now we know, thanks JP I agree, I think it is BS and he just likes to sound like a tough guy. Well if it makes you feel better to talk about killing cats to compensate for your short comings be my guest. "

    jp wrote on Jun 25, 2009 7:33 AM:

    " well then, bring your cat over and i'll demonstrate it for you! "

    To JP wrote on Jun 23, 2009 4:27 PM:

    " I call BS. You did not shoot the neighbors cat nor did you deliver it to the said neighbor. Also I doubt you own a freshly painted 1928 Model A. You are just try to convince everybody that you are some tough lawless Alaskans that does whatever they want. Well I call BS. You sir are no real representation of Valley people or Alaskans for that matter. "

    jp wrote on Jun 23, 2009 12:34 PM:

    " The neighbors cat jumped up on the hood of my freshly painted 1928 Model A .
    I shot the cat, and hand delivered it back to my neighbor.
    Keep you pets in your own yard!!! "

    Keep your cats home wrote on Jun 23, 2009 9:29 AM:

    " That is the best thing to learn from this. All of our animals are safer if we keep our animals home. I don't let my dog roam free. It would not be safe. It is amazing to me that cats are allowed to roam free and kill birds as much as they want. If a dog killed that much it would be called vicious and be put to death. I love birds and don't like cats because of their need to kill birds just for the fun of it. Keep your cats home. "

    Get a clue wrote on Jun 22, 2009 11:27 PM:

    " It is not so much about the cat but more about the safety of the public and the stupidity of the person who set the trap. Trapping is fine when done in legal areas and during trapping season. Even setting a trap on your own property can be illegal. Just ask the guy from Anchorage who got a fine and jail time for a trap on his porch. "

    Barbar s wrote on Jun 22, 2009 5:34 PM:

    " yOU SILLY SILLY WOMAN IT'S YOUR OWN FAULT IF YOU LET YOUR PETS ROME FREE. oNE WOULD THINK THE FIRST CAT LOST WOULD TEACH YOU. Local law #2405070= the restraint of animals law you need to read "

    Who says the trap was on public land wrote on Jun 22, 2009 10:27 AM:

    " Since the cat can't talk and was allowed to roam where it chose, who says it got trapped on public land or near neighborhoods. This cat could have gotten the trap an someones property. I am not saying I like traps, but my birds have been victims of cats many times. Cats kill many more small creatures then we give them credit for. I am saying that this cat could have been trapped on private property and the best for all is for the cat owners to keep their pets at home. "

    Come on wrote on Jun 22, 2009 10:25 AM:

    " Why should we feel bad for the woman who lets her cats run completely loose. How about all the song birds that cat has killed? "

    Tried wrote on Jun 21, 2009 5:21 PM:

    " It still amzaes me that people blame others, when they let their animal runs free and they get hurt. This is the ladies second cat, you'd think she'd learn. "

    No snares wrote on Jun 21, 2009 4:53 PM:

    " Yes snares are set all the time but to put one on public land near a neighborhood is stupid. If you have a farm and need them to protect your animals then set them on the edge of your property. But to set them in the woods on borough land or federal land out of trapping season or near a neighborhood is lame and just perpetuates the stereo type of dumb valley hick. Sorry but you little white trashville is growing up. It is called population. "

    Cats should be kept home wrote on Jun 21, 2009 1:12 PM:

    " They kill many small birds too. Cats cause a lot of destruction and they can roam for many miles if you let your cat do that. It is not safe for the cat or any small birds that get in their way. We used to have many spruce hens until the neighbors moved in with all their cats. These cats sit on my property and hunt birds all day every day. So keep your cats home and they will be safe and so will the other little creatures cats kill for the fun of it. "

    snares are set for animals all the time in the Valley wrote on Jun 21, 2009 1:07 PM:

    " Farmers set traps to get rid of the animals that are killing their poultry. No one wants to talk about that. We've had cats come in to our yard and kill our chickens many times over the years. We have a totally fenced in chicken pen and the cats just climb a tree and jump in and kill the small chickens. People should keep their cats home if they want them to be safe. I will dispatch any animal that comes in to my yard and kills my poultry unless it is a protected animal. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   




Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage