Union, Walgreens dispute standards

BY GREG JOHNSON
Frontiersman
Published on Saturday, July 17, 2010 8:46 PM AKDT

WASILLA — Walgreens bills itself as “the pharmacy America trusts,” but that doesn’t include the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America.

Members of the trade workers union have been demonstrating against the pharmacy chain over claims Walgreens fails to meet local area labor standards when constructing its buildings. Drivers on the Parks Highway near the Wasilla outlet may have noticed over the past month people displaying a large sign proclaiming “Shame on Walgreens.”

The demonstration is manned by members of the Alaska Regional Council of Carpenters, which is affiliated with the union. Although the sign also proclaims a “labor dispute,” it’s aimed at Walgreens corporate construction practices and not at employees of the local store, said Arylis Scates, director of organizing for the council.

ROBERT DeBERRY/Frontiersman Three United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America union members stand with a banner protesting Walgreens along the Parks Highway Friday afternoon.

“Walgreens started off as a great company doing everything correctly,” he said. “They were meeting standards in most areas and doing things above the board.”

That has changed in recent years when the company began receiving a string of multi-million dollar judgments and settlements against it, he said. Now, the union claims Walgreens hires substandard contractors to do construction work who often don’t offer a living wage or health insurance. It’s a claim he said is aimed at the corporation and not necessarily the way the Wasilla store, which opened last year, was built.

“As Walgreens started to lose these mulit-million dollar lawsuits, they also started to wane on their area standards,” he said. “Instead of saying, ‘We need to turn this around and improve our standards,’ they decided to take a corporate action of cutting more corners and employ less-than-area-standards contractors.”

Those lawsuits include a 2008 $24 million settlement of a lawsuit filed by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission for alleged race discrimination. Earlier this year, the company settled a deceptive marketing complaint brought by the Federal Trade Commission for $6 million. Walgreens was hit with a $25.8 million judgment for the 2007 death of a Florida woman that was caused by a prescription mistake. The largest blow came in 2008, when the company settled a Medicaid whistleblower lawsuit for $35 million.

A call to the Wasilla Walgreens for comment was referred to Robert Elfinger, a media relations specialist for the company in Illinois. Elfinger said Walgreens disputes the union’s claims and acknowledged there are similar demonstrations at stores throughout the United States. He declined to answer questions about the union’s specific grievances, saying the company’s position is outlined in a statement.

“We require that all developers and contractors who build or remodel Walgreens stores offer their employees health insurance benefits and a living wage,” the statement says. “We also encourage union contractors to submit bids, and a great number of our construction jobs are performed with union labor. We require that our developers and contractors bid our jobs to both union and nonunion contractors and when bids are competitive, we favor union labor.”

Scates said the issue isn’t whether Walgreens uses union or nonunion labor.

“It does not matter if it’s union or not,” he said. “I want them to meet that standard. ... If they were doing the responsible thing, (Walgreens would) employ contractors who have already gone through the proper steps. These are people who have taken time out of their lives to learn their trade, improve their trade.”

The Wasilla demonstration is peaceful, Scates said, adding the goal is to educate people about the union’s complaint.

“We want people to see that sign and wonder why,” he said. “Hopefully, they’ll go over and ask about it, then do their own due diligence to learn about it.”

Contact Greg Johnson at greg.johnson@frontiersman.com or 352-2269

Comments

40 comment(s)

    GO WALGREENS wrote on Aug 29, 2010 9:16 PM:

    " I am a loyal employee for Walgreen's. I have been employed for 4 years & it is the best job I could have. I had a customer approach the protesters the other day, and he said, "that they were rude." So why would people want to go up to them and ask questions? I just wanted to say that the protesters have brought us more business. So thank you. The protesters need to get a real job, and I agree they don't look the part. "

    Mo wrote on Aug 3, 2010 1:08 PM:

    " Here's a clue... If you don't like it, don't shop there. If you aren't getting enough work because you are crying while leaning on a protest sign, get a real job! Unions have outlived their usefulness. Why is it so bad that a PRIVATE company decided to exercise their FREEDOM to choose a contractor as they see fit? That's not un-American, it's just un-union.

    I for one stepped-up my monetary contributions to Walgreen's in light of the "protest". "

    Unions are old news wrote on Jul 27, 2010 8:35 PM:

    " Perhaps the unions should take another look. PEOPLE HATE UNIONS! They overstayed their welcome at the last election when they decided to push their members to vote for anti small business candidates and used their MIGHT. I agree with the rest, I WILL BE SHOPPING AT WALGREENS MORE NOW! "

    union princesses at walgreens wrote on Jul 26, 2010 9:19 PM:

    " instead of worrying about what walgreens is doing, why not focus on your own problem: declining membership. "

    Debs wrote on Jul 26, 2010 12:53 PM:

    " I have been a member of 4 unions during my life, and what I saw repeatedly (and in them all) were some people that were lazy or worthless and they NEVER got fired.....most filed a suit and ended up with money. I challenge anyone in any union out there to contradict that one you are a union member, its impossible to get rid of you, even if you are impossibly worthless. "

    sethinak wrote on Jul 25, 2010 10:39 AM:

    " we got out of state people coming up here and working cheap, unless you're a contractor that makes all the money on the worker's backs, i don't get the anti-union sentiment. all tradesman's wages would be much lower without the labor unions. "

    Rusty wrote on Jul 24, 2010 9:47 PM:

    " Whining punk crybaby union thugs. I will shop as much as possible at Walgreens from now on. "

    HEY CJ wrote on Jul 24, 2010 2:03 PM:

    " i have worked for a union. why did i have to pay money to keep my job? if i was a good, qualified, competent employee, why did i need collective bargaining?

    my skills speak for themselves. now, i make more with a non-union electric company and ALL of my money goes to ME. "

    Milka wrote on Jul 24, 2010 10:20 AM:

    " Thank you for running this article and claryfication. The union demonstrators are totally misleading. Shame on them. "

    Rose wrote on Jul 24, 2010 10:19 AM:

    " Having union employees to operate federal contracts is costly and prohibitive to operate federal contracts because of their high demands of more money annually. Inn effect, they are running themselves out of a job because the federal government then looks for contractors who bid lower for operations. "

    To CJ wrote on Jul 23, 2010 10:39 PM:

    " That was the funniest bunch of bull i have read in weeks.

    get your unions jackalopes back to work instead of standing on the corner like crying bums. "

    Mark ABQ wrote on Jul 23, 2010 3:45 PM:

    " Protesters with same sign in Albuquerque, NM - has been over 100 degrees all week....... "

    Why wrote on Jul 23, 2010 2:14 PM:

    " Why are they protesting then? If Walgreens had done anything wrong the NLRB would have shut them down immediately! The NLRB uses taxpayer dollars to give support to the unions - anyone who has dealt with either knows that for a fact - they even laugh about it! The fact that the NLRB is not involved when it would love to be tells me nothing is wrong with Walgreens!! Unions had a place before we had extensive laws and regs for workers. Now they are antiques that feed off the system costing employers and employees. "

    khbalaska wrote on Jul 23, 2010 9:18 AM:

    " Wow, if not for this article explaining exactly what those people are doing out there we'd never know that they weren't just picketing our local Walgreens. Rather disingenuous of them if you ask me. "

    CJ wrote on Jul 23, 2010 7:33 AM:

    " All of you ! unless you work for the Union, you have no idea how much work it involves to set up a Collective Agreement with contractors and upkeep the admin side of things for all the union members . Union members must attend schooling to become Journeyman. The tests are hard and you must get 70% or more to pass. Union members get paid well and have good pension plan, due to their extensive knowlege of the trade. They build above code to keep everyone safe. With Unions Safety is the key, good future for all. "

    brady7 wrote on Jul 22, 2010 11:15 AM:

    " Why is it everyone wants to look @ this issue from their perspective and not the big picture? Area standards is nothing more than a contractor paying a liveable wage, health benefits, and some type of retirement. If they do not share with those doing the work, then @ 50 plus years old we will all be paying to take care of those workers with our tax dollars. "

    Chris wrote on Jul 21, 2010 1:30 AM:

    " To union wife: Sorry but the majority of Unions out there are a waste. Teacher's and Auto Workers are the worst. You don't believe me? Look at our education system and the Auto industry. Thos in the Teachers union cant be fired so it doesn't matter if their average is a C, they are failing the kids and they don't care. They have a nice cushy job and guess what, they know they can't get fired. Auto, well do I really need to go into detail their? "

    Bravo wrote on Jul 20, 2010 1:40 PM:

    " Yay! It is so awesome to read so many comments of people who see through the unions! I've felt like I was the only one out here! As a teacher, I'd LOVE to get rid of our union. I've always thought it was so wrong that we are forced to belong to the union in order to be employed in a profession we love. Alaska is NOT a right to work state, (if it was, I wouldn't have to belong to this union) but that's something we should work on. "

    Jen wrote on Jul 20, 2010 10:47 AM:

    " Well, I am technically a union member because I pay my dues - but I am not a 'real' union member because I refuse to let any of my money get donated to Democrat candidates.
    Unions are good and bad. Regardless of your thoughts on Unions, Walgreens should be building everything to code as they should. If they aren't, the Union needs to get specific complaints rather than just a sign in Wasilla, AK. "

    Rebecca Logan wrote on Jul 19, 2010 9:33 PM:

    " Throughout the story the union claims that this has nothing to do with the local store or the local contractors who worked on the store. So, in other words, they are deceiving the public when they stand in front of the local store claiming a labor dispute. And they wonder why people don't trust them? And for the blogger who tried to distort Beck - Beck simply allowed workers who were forced to join a union only to pay dues that were used for bargaining. They still have to pay dues - "

    union wife wrote on Jul 19, 2010 5:49 PM:

    " I Love and agree with the union in what they are stating the union has been nothing but good to me and my family if u dont like them watch the high cost of low prices you might then understand the why unions are great! "

    Brian Gundlach wrote on Jul 19, 2010 5:41 PM:

    " If the this union's intent is to ensure Walgreens compliance with the law they need to cite specific charges and bring suit. Otherwise they need to quit acting like vagrants on the side oof the Parks highway. "

    MSBoro Employees and teachers wrote on Jul 19, 2010 2:40 PM:

    " In order to be an employee for the Matanuska Susitna Borough, you are now required to join a union whether you want to or not. Same with teachers. Gatto and several others worked on an amendment to make it so an employee was not required to join a union in order to obtain a job at businesses or government agencies. Unfortunately, it hasn't gone very far. Suggestion to employees: Terminate your union at the end of your next contract. "

    area labor standards wrote on Jul 19, 2010 1:39 PM:

    " like what?
    osha covers workers safety.
    bidding covers workers pay.
    insurance covers workers comp.
    best practices cover workers skills.
    state labor laws covers workers rights.

    nope. no real issue. sorry union thug.

    you lose.

    ps- when you see these kooks on the corner holding their sign, tell them off! "

    Get your facts straight wrote on Jul 19, 2010 9:02 AM:

    " You do not have to join a union making Alaska a “right to work state” is a waste of time.
    A decade ago, the U. S. Supreme Court established what are now known as "Beck rights" in the landmark decision Communication Workers v. Beck.1 Beck rights dictate that workers cannot be forced under union contracts to pay any dues or fees. Beck rights are a triumph of individual rights over the political weight of union leaders. "

    exunion member wrote on Jul 19, 2010 7:54 AM:

    " wow cant believe they are out there with their signs. Imagine if they had the brains to start a company and build it over years. Then they start to expand and someone comes in and tells them they have to pay 2 times as much for the same work or possibly even poorer work since it is hard to fire the bad ones out of the union. GO WALGREENS I will be shopping there more. When all the jobs are in China then maybe the unions will be happy. Their time has come and gone. "

    Pay Attention wrote on Jul 19, 2010 6:22 AM:

    " If you look at what the Union is saying you should applaud what they are doing. Walgreens is apparently trying to make up the judgements by cutting corners, i.e. not hiring contractors that meet area labor standards. The Union even says in the article it's not about being Union, it's about hiring contractors that pay a living wage and provide benefits. Union is not a dirty word, they've done a lot to help this country. If you have healthcare, a retirment and get paid overtime for more than 40 hrs. thank the Unions! "

    dear susan wrote on Jul 18, 2010 10:18 PM:

    " If people are taking the jobs, then it is a living wage for someone. If they do not pay enough, then no body will take the jobs. The workers have all the power. Kind of ironic that the same people who are pro-union are also in favor of allowing all the illegals into the country to take these jobs for a lower wage. If you eliminate all the illegals who will work for a low wage, companies will have to increase what they pay. I dont hold what a company pays people against them at all. "

    Meadow Lakes Madman wrote on Jul 18, 2010 9:01 PM:

    " Union bashing, go figure....they deserve it. "

    Susan wrote on Jul 18, 2010 6:36 PM:

    " I'm not understanding all the Union hating? It seems they aren't saying only Union workers can do the job right, but they want to insure whoever is doing the work is "up to area standards". Unfortunately the story didn't clarify what those standard discrepancies are.
    Wouldn't it be great if everyone could make a decent living for an honest days work and not try and tear each other down. "

    Metoo wrote on Jul 18, 2010 2:42 PM:

    " So anyone can put up a sign. City code enforcement looks the other way. Great location for another off premises sign coming soon. "

    Leon wrote on Jul 18, 2010 1:55 PM:

    " being Union makes you better???more qualified? I will match up against your Union personal for experience "on the job" actual labor experience- then we will see who is better...
    Paying someone for my experience who purportedly found me a job when my experience got me the job is a true qualified person. "

    right to work wrote on Jul 18, 2010 1:12 PM:

    " Alaska is NOT a right to work state. Learn what that means....I recommend wikipedia.

    We need to BECOME a Right to work state- that way, you are not forced to join a union to, for example, become a teacher.

    Down with all unions. Tis is not 1936 any longer. "

    Simple Math wrote on Jul 18, 2010 11:34 AM:

    " If union costs weren't so high they'd find more work!! Simple economics. Pretty sad when Alaska jobs are being farmed out to companies in the lower 48 because its cheaper. Wake up union!! "

    wrote on Jul 18, 2010 10:09 AM:

    " I too am sick and tired of Union and Government employees and that whiners attitude both portray. But I do forget that this country has changed from the ours to the I got mine attitude, it is most visible with those in the public service fields, they all work for and yet complain about the man, about time to issue some state and federal pink slips is my opinion. "

    AKwasilla wrote on Jul 18, 2010 10:09 AM:

    " So if you don't work for a union you haven't taken the time and effort to be the best at what you do?
    Shame on the union for assuming that if your not part of the union your not smart enough to do a job right.
    Get OFF the street corner and do something that really counts, I’m sick of seeing unprofessional looking workers trying to make their point! If you want people to listen them maybe you should look and act the part! "

    tradalaskan wrote on Jul 18, 2010 9:15 AM:

    " I am so sick of whiny unions. They are the scourge of our country that have outlived there usefulness. "

    Get to work wrote on Jul 18, 2010 9:13 AM:

    " There are plenty of stimulus dollarsfor you union workers to be employed. Anyone know how much those guys out there are making per hour, or are they volunteering their time? Sounds to me like Walgreens is doing us all a favor by not allowing the Unions to bully them into taking Union bids, likely at a higher overall price. It's a competitive process, so if you can't compete on your bid it is up to the UNION to figure it out. Quit complaining and get to "work." "

    Bravo wrote on Jul 18, 2010 9:12 AM:

    " Bravo to Walgreen's for not bowing down to union pressure! This country is becoming tired of the constant whining of unions. They are a big reason our country is struggling. "

    lifelongalaska wrote on Jul 18, 2010 7:43 AM:

    " Frontiersman, get the story straight. This is about the unions wanting all the money. Alaska needs to stay a "right to work" state in order to be competitive. There is alot of work right now, these protesters are only patsies for the rich union bosses! "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   








Classifieds




Make Us Your Homepage