To the editor:
Imagine sharing Knik-Goose Bay Road, already a designated safety corridor, and the Glenn Highway with 75-ton coal trucks making 100 daily round trips from Sutton. Now add even more trucks a day if a coal mine near Chickaloon becomes reality.
People in the Mat-Su Borough should be aware of the proposed coal mining by Usibelli near Sutton. Less people are aware of the coal exploration by an Australian corporation, Riversdale, that proposes developing a coal mine near Chickaloon. Both companies plan to ship coal to Japan, South Korea and China using the port at Point MacKenzie.
If you do not live near any of the proposed coal mining sites, you may be feeling good that you won’t have to deal with noise pollution, coal dust, polluted watersheds, reduced recreational opportunity and lower property values. But if these mines come to fruition, for coal to be shipped out of Alaska, the companies plan on using the Port MacKenzie, which puts the coal in the backyards of the Palmer-Wasilla area. The only means of transporting coal to port at this time is with 75-ton coal trucks, and the only route is via the Glenn Highway, directly through Palmer, on through Wasilla, then via Knik-Goose Bay Road, where accidents already happen too frequently.
There is no infrastructure in place to handle the transport of coal. These trucks will be going through the intersections your children cross to attend school, they will be sharing roads not only with your personal vehicles, but with all the buses full of your children. Do you think our road systems are prepared to handle the daily onslaught of these trucks? Are you prepared to put up with the increased traffic and possible coal dust? As these roads deteriorate, who pays for the upkeep? The Mat-Su Borough does not have a natural resource extraction fee; there would be no benefit to lower property taxes (unless you consider lower property values a benefit).
Whether you think coal is an archaic energy source or still a viable energy option, and while coal companies and the current borough administration tout coal mining as an economic boon for the area, when one weighs all the pitfalls of road maintenance, coal dust pollution and the dangers of sharing our already congested highways with 75-ton coal trucks, there really is little or no economic gain for the Mat-Su Borough — although the coal companies will be counting up their profits at our loss.
Craig Baer
Sutton
Post a comment as
Report
Watch this discussion.
(16) comments
Excellent piece , I Appreciate the info , Does anyone know where my company would be able to grab a template US Chile Free Trade Agreement copy to work with ?
Follow the money, you really made me laugh with that old case (1958). You peaked my interest as I hunt the area where the old mine site of Suntrana used to be. It has been gone for many decades and in fact nothing is left but a few artifacts you can find here and there. For you to try to fault a dead man, Mr. Usibelli for something that was common practice in the 1950's shows the leave to which you anti mining folks will go. Mining today has very little in common with what it was in the 1950's. The same goes for Colstrip. Today is vastly different than when the former company left back in the 60's. Unfortunately you present this in a way to mislead people to believing this is how things are still done when you know better. Walk Healy creek as I do and you will know the truth. This is a beautiful area full of wildlife, clean air, and water. Usibelli is a good company that employs Alaskans at excellent wages.
Read how Riversdale totally disrupts, displaces and destroys communities:
Google: Coal versus Communities by the South African Resource Watch
MtMike, if any of the mine supporters bothered to research, they would find what you and I have found.....Usibelli has many past environmental citations documented in federal records.
In the Suntrana vs. Usibelli case, by admission of Usibelli himself, Usibelli has dumped a huge amount of mine waste into Healy River:
"In his testimony, Mr. Usibelli, the head of the company, estimated that over 4,000,000 cubic yards of mine waste and overburden have been removed from his operation and that approximately 64,000 cubic yards have remained deposited in a pit area located on his leasehold. The remainder, consisting of 3,936,000 cubic yards, has been deposited by Usibelli into the waters and upon the flood plane of the Healy River."
Pay closer attention, contrarian, and you will figure it out....the money trail is easy, you just have to do a bit of research and keep your eyes & ears open.
[wink]
@ onermailliw
"Oh and the penalty from the EPA was in regards to a settling ponds that overflowed during a record rain season."
You supporters of the mine who are supporting the special interest crooks in power, can not even connect your lies to make sense, you were babbling about a "record rain season" for the penalties occurred at Usibelli.!.
Read when the offenses occurred -
According to documents associated with the case, the Mine had 11 unpermitted discharges into the Nenana River, Hoseanna Creek, Sanderson Creek, and Francis Creek between April 2007 and July 2010. During that time, they also had 10 violations of their discharge permit limits-
Some record rain season, lasted 4 years!
Get a clue! Learning from what happens in Montana, West Virginia is how one becomes a better, cleaner miner.
The current Alaska Government Philosophy of: "If you build it, they will come", is followed by, then what? More crime, sprawl, road congestion, more government, higher taxes and fees, like what is now happening in Anchorage, Palmer and Wasilla?
Clueless is how one would best describe Alaska political leaders!
The coal should be left in the ground to turn into diamonds. It is primitive to burn coal, anymore. Yes, follow the money, it is all about kickbacks and favors and profit for a few miserable people. We should rise out of the coal age, and seek enlightenment.
Check out the Parnell Plan for gutting regulations and speeding up the permitting process for mining corporations....definitely not in the best interest of the people of Alaska.
Read about how AIDEA is planning on spending taxpayers dollars to help out those poor multi-billion dollar coal corporates by providing infrastructure needed for transportation of coal.
Follow taxpayers money to kickbacks, payouts and contracts of individuals who keep saying this is all in the public interest, when in fact the dollars keep accumulating in the bank accounts of elected officials and their friends. Corruption at its finest.
William, Oldgeezer and Not Buying have it exactly right. I hunt in the Healy area and it is beautiful. The mine is clean and well run with no ill effects on the area, except good paying jobs( we all know how bad having money is) 58% ABOVE the per capita income of Palmer. The people in town live very close to the mine 2 to 3 miles and have an excellent relationship with it.
Mining is esential to our High Quality American lifestyle. The copper wires in your home that carry electricity came from mining. As did the steel in your cars and truck, the precious metals in your computer, the zinc in your pennies and the nickle in your nickles. The list is endless.
Mt.Mike- Don't know if you have heard this before, but we don't care how they do it in Montana. Alaska has some of the strongest enviromental regulations in the world. Oh and the penalty from the EPA was in regards to a settling ponds that overflowed during a record rain season.
Craig, you nailed it. Riversdale and Usibelli corporations are prime examples of corporate greed.
"The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which."
--GEORGE ORWELL, Animal Farm
Usibelli Coal Mine, near Healy, Alaska, agrees to pay $60,000 EPA penalty for Clean Water Act violations
Release Date: 01/20/2011
Contact Information: Eva DeMaria, EPA NPDES Compliance Unit, (206) 553-1970, demaria.eva@epa.gov Tony Brown, EPA Public Affairs, (206) 553-1203, brown.anthony@epa.gov
According to documents associated with the case, the Mine had 11 unpermitted discharges into the Nenana River, Hoseanna Creek, Sanderson Creek, and Francis Creek between April 2007 and July 2010. During that time, they also had 10 violations of their discharge permit limits.
Maybe, if people were not so lazy, they could do their own research.
Research for yourself and find out the TRUE story behind strip coal mining, whether Alaska, or Montana or West Virginia and then make up your own minds.
Do not believe the "hype" of those who will gain the fiscal rewards from strip coal mining in the Wasilla/Palmer/Sutton/Chickaloon areas. Find out for yourself!
Then decide!
I am not in favor of polluting water, creating noxious dust or tearing up roads. But can you explain how that coal mine in Healy hasn't destroyed all the scenery and water between Healy and Seward over the last 40 years?
More anti coal sillyness.
I would like to hear comments from some of the residents of Healy where modern Alaska coal mining is now done. A few years ago I had the opportunity to tour the Usibili coal mine up there. I was very favorably impressed in several ways. IT was neat, clean and very well maintained. The family attmosphere was everywhere. Nice folks that treated each other with respect and a community of caring was reflected in everywhere I looked.
The environment appeared to have been nicely reclaimed and reseeded by someone that had expertise in Alaskan flora.
I left with the feeling that wished I lived closer so that I could join in working and living with them.
All it takes is some research to find the true story on Coal Mining.
I came to Alaska from Montana. I recommend anyone to research Colstrip, Montana. A strip coal mining community.
Here are some excerpts from David Hansen and Colstrip.
"Colstrip had experienced dramatic increases in alcoholism, drug abuse, crime and a range of related social problems"
and another:
"the most difficult aspect of mine reclamation, reconstituting the groundwater system, remains a problem without a solution. The mining process inevitably disturbs or cuts off natural drainage patterns. The major aquifers in the area are located in the coal seam and some sandstone layers above it. The aquifers are disrupted indefinitely when they are intersected by the mining, draining precious water into the mine pits, contaminating it with acid runoff from the mines and spoil piles, and polluting it with silt and toxic metals. As the water tables in the area are lowered, both the quantity and quality of water downgrade are affected. In this semi-arid terrain, the barely adequate water supply is critical for agriculture and grazing. Even farmers and ranchers far from the mine have had problems with their wells being contaminated or drying up. Most of the town’s wells were severely contaminated and have been closed."
I recommend anyone to research and form your own opinion.on strip coal mining in Alaska or anywhere. The results are not good!
more on Colstrip
"The Colstrip power plant is the second largest coal-fired power plant west of the Mississippi. It is the tallest man-made structure in Montana, with stacks that rise over 700 feet into the sky. It is now owned by a consortium of power companies and produces more than 2.2 million kilowatts of electricity a year. Over two-thirds of the electricity is exported to the Pacific Northwest via an extensive system of power transmission corridors cutting a swath 300 feet wide across nearly 1500 miles. The mines and industrial site extend over 50 square miles. Since the mines first opened in 1924, over 550 million tons of coal have been dug up. Enough earth has been moved to fill both the Erie and Panama canals five times over. Yet there are still more than 120 billion tons of coal reserves in Montana: 25 percent of the total coal reserves in the United States."
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.